Second-chance tenancies and security of tenure
The subdistrict court of North Holland refuses the eviction of a social housing property. A sublease described as a 'second-chance tenancy agreement' did not meet the strict requirements of the Decree on Specific Groups for Temporary Tenancy Agreements. As a result, the statutory security of tenure continued to apply and the tenancy did not end merely because the fixed term expired.
Municipality lets a social housing property as a 'second chance' through a sublease
On 14 April 2026, the subdistrict court of North Holland (Zaanstad location) refused, in preliminary relief proceedings (kort geding), the eviction of a social housing property. A municipality had let that property to a tenant as a 'second chance' but did not manage to terminate the tenancy validly. The background is a living situation that had got out of hand.
The tenant had rented the property from the housing association Parteon since 2015. Owing to compulsive hoarding, the property became heavily soiled and a fire hazard arose; in September 2024 the municipality imposed an order subject to administrative enforcement (last onder bestuursdwang). Parteon brought preliminary relief proceedings for eviction, which ended in a settlement: the tenancy with Parteon would end and the tenant would be given another property through a care institution, with support and an evaluation after twelve months.
Because no care institution was willing to act as tenant and sub-landlord, the municipality took on that role. It rented the property from Parteon and sublet it to the tenant. The written contract referred to a 'second-chance contract' under the Decree on Specific Groups for Temporary Tenancy Agreements. When the evaluation turned out negative, the municipality gave notice terminating the sublease with effect from 9 February 2026 and claimed eviction, on the ground that the tenancy had ended through the expiry of the fixed term.
Subdistrict court: the Decree on Specific Groups must be interpreted strictly
The main rule is that a tenancy of residential accommodation for a fixed term does not end merely through the expiry of that term (Section 7:271(1) DCC). A notice from the landlord does not itself bring that tenancy to an end (Section 7:272(1) DCC). An exception to that security of tenure exists for temporary contracts of no more than two years with specific groups of tenants, designated in the Decree on Specific Groups for Temporary Tenancy Agreements. One of those groups is the tenant with whom the landlord enters into a second-chance tenancy agreement.
Because this regime forms an exception to security of tenure, the subdistrict court interprets it strictly: the mere label 'second-chance contract' is insufficient. It went wrong on three points. First, the municipality was not the earlier landlord, that was Parteon, so there was no second chance with the same landlord. Second, the earlier tenancy with Parteon had ended through a settlement and not through judicial termination on the ground of serious nuisance; it had not been sufficiently argued that an eviction would very probably have been granted. Third, the case concerned a sublease agreement, whereas the Decree assumes a regular tenancy agreement.
The conclusion is that there had been no valid derogation from the statutory security of tenure, so that the tenancy did not end on 9 February 2026 and the tenant was not occupying the property without right or title. In addition, the sublease of a self-contained dwelling is, on the ending of the head lease, continued by operation of law by the landlord, here Parteon (Section 7:269(1) DCC). By that route too, a ground for eviction was lacking. The municipality was ordered to pay the costs of the proceedings of €1,009.
What does this mean for landlords wishing to offer a second chance?
Bespoke arrangements within tenancy law require clarity in advance about the applicable statutory exception. The court interpreted the second-chance exception strictly in this case. Anyone wishing to enter into a second-chance tenancy agreement must themselves be the landlord giving the tenant a fresh chance, and must be able to substantiate that the earlier contract ended through the courts or through a forced departure on the ground of serious nuisance. According to this court, the sublease arrangement through the municipality fell outside that exception.
Municipalities and housing associations wishing to help vulnerable tenants are therefore well advised to have the arrangement assessed legally in advance. If it does not fit within the Decree on Specific Groups, a tenancy agreement with full security of tenure arises unintentionally, precisely the opposite of the intended temporary nature. An agreement that the tenant will leave later likewise holds up only if the tenant knowingly gives up security of tenure; see buying out a tenant before a sale.
Frequently asked questions
When does a temporary tenancy of residential accommodation end automatically?
For the groups designated in the Decree on Specific Groups for Temporary Tenancy Agreements, a contract of no more than two years can end on expiry. The landlord must give written notification no earlier than three months and no later than one month before the end (Section 7:271(2) DCC). Simply including an end date in the contract is insufficient.
What is a second-chance tenancy agreement?
A temporary contract of no more than two years giving a tenant a fresh chance after serious nuisance. According to the court, the landlord must be the same, and the earlier tenancy must have ended by judicial decision or a settlement because eviction would very probably have been ordered. The Decree on Specific Groups is interpreted strictly.
What happens to a subtenant when the head lease ends?
Where the subtenant has their principal residence in self-contained accommodation, the head landlord continues the sublease (Section 7:269(1) DCC). That landlord can seek judicial termination within six months on the statutory grounds (Section 7:269(2) DCC). The end of the head lease therefore does not automatically require the subtenant to leave.
Cited case law
District Courts
- North Holland District Court (preliminary relief) 14 April 2026, ECLI:NL:RBNHO:2026:3990: The sublease labelled a second-chance tenancy did not meet the exception; security of tenure remained and eviction was refused (paras 4.18-4.27).