Skip to content

Commercial lease law: termination, defects and service charges

30 March 2026Juriaan de Vries

Commercial leases: termination, defects and service charges

For commercial premises, the lease regime determines how the landlord can give notice and when the tenant must leave. The contract carries particular weight for defects and service charges. This analysis covers five linked questions: whether there is a lease, what protection applies, when rescission is available, who bears defects and which costs can be passed on.

First establish whether there is a lease

A lease requires the use of property in return for consideration (Section 7:201(1) DCC). Without consideration, the arrangement may be a loan for use (bruikleen, Section 7A:1777 DCC), to which lease protection does not apply. For temporary occupation of vacant buildings, the purpose of any monthly payment therefore matters.

The court first identifies the agreed rights and obligations, applying the Haviltex standard. It then classifies the agreement under the law. The chosen label or wish to avoid lease protection does not determine that classification. The Supreme Court explained these two stages in agricultural tenancy and employment cases (Supreme Court 13 March 1981, assessment of the ground of appeal; Supreme Court 20 December 2019, paras 3.2.2-3.2.3; Supreme Court 6 November 2020, paras 3.2.2-3.2.3).

A payment covering specific occupation and management costs need not be rent. Its amount alone does not decide the issue. In a vacant-property case, a €150 monthly payment could be explained by a schedule of costs totalling €177.50 after correction. The Supreme Court quashed the finding of a lease for inadequate reasoning; classification remained open following remittal. A party relying on management costs must therefore explain what the payment covers (Supreme Court 2 June 2023, paras 3.2.2-3.2.4).

Owner’s maintenance or financing costs must be distinguished from the occupant’s own costs of use. Work can also constitute consideration. In another case, €150 per month together with mandatory maintenance and supervision of land the occupants did not use amounted to sufficient consideration for a lease (Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal 2021, paras 5.14-5.19).

Section 230a: the lease may end before occupation does

Section 7:230a DCC applies to built premises that are neither residential accommodation nor Section 290 premises, typically offices, warehouses and professional practice space. The landlord need not identify a specified statutory ground for notice. The contract must still be followed, including the notice period and any requirement for a registered letter or bailiff’s writ.

A fixed term expires without notice unless a renewal arrangement provides otherwise. Early termination by notice requires a contractual right. If the tenant remains with the landlord’s consent, Section 7:230 DCC generally extends the lease indefinitely, unless a different intention appears. The statutory notice period is at least one month, ending on an agreed rent payment day (Section 7:228(2) DCC); the contract may require longer notice. Reasonableness and fairness can impose further conditions where statute and contract leave room. The general standard was explained in a licensing dispute, rather than a lease case (Supreme Court 2 February 2018, paras 3.6.2-3.7).

The landlord must give written notice requiring possession on a specified date at or after the end of the lease. The tenant has two months from the date specified for giving up possession to petition for an extension. The landlord cannot require possession during that period. A timely petition suspends the obligation to leave until the court decides. The period therefore does not start when the letter is sent.

The court compares the harm to the tenant and any authorised subtenant from leaving with the harm to the landlord if occupation continues. Serious nuisance, improper use or non-payment may make continued occupation unreasonable. The first extension lasts no later than one year after the lease ends, with up to two further one-year extensions. A further petition must be filed at least a month before expiry. This postpones possession; it does not renew the lease.

The protection cannot be excluded in advance. It is unavailable where the tenant gave notice, expressly agreed to termination, or was ordered to leave for breach. Later arrangements therefore require assessment of their precise content and how they were made. There is generally no appeal or appeal in cassation against the decision, subject to exceptional grounds for setting aside the appeal bar.

Section 290: notice requires statutory scrutiny

Shops and hospitality premises falling within Section 7:290 DCC enjoy extensive security of tenure. The landlord must give at least one year’s notice by registered letter or bailiff’s writ. Classification depends on the agreed use; the contract’s label is insufficient.

The main rule is five years, extended by statute to normally ten years; a longer agreed first term can alter that division (Section 7:292 DCC). A separate exception applies to leases of no more than two years, outside Sections 7:291-300 DCC. If occupation continues beyond two years, the five-year regime generally follows, with those two years deducted. After the statutory terms, the lease normally continues indefinitely unless a new fixed term is agreed. Provisions detrimental to the tenant may require court approval.

At the end of the first statutory term, Section 7:296 DCC provides two grounds: business conduct falling short of a good tenant’s obligations, and the landlord’s urgent need for personal, lasting use. The first ground concerns the seriousness of the conduct as a whole; multiple incidents are not an absolute requirement. Fault or specific loss is not a separate condition. Personal use includes the spouse, registered partner, first-degree relatives by blood or marriage and foster children specified by law. Use by an affiliated company does not qualify automatically. The need for personal use is assessed against the circumstances at the time of the court’s decision. Renovation falls within this ground if it requires termination of the lease. A successor landlord must consider the statutory three-year waiting period and its exceptions.

After the second statutory term, further grounds concern refusal of a reasonable offer for a new agreement and implementing the use assigned by the environmental plan (omgevingsplan). The designated use and a genuine intention to implement it must be established. Rent changes have their own procedure under Section 7:303 DCC. A reasonable weighing of interests can also justify termination. The wish to re-let the same premises at a higher rent to a comparable tenant was insufficient (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2024, paras 3.10-3.12).

If the landlord has not received written consent six weeks after giving notice, a termination claim can be brought on the grounds stated in that notice. Those six weeks are not a forfeiture period for the tenant. Without written consent, the lease generally continues until the decision is final. If the defence is manifestly unfounded, the court can declare its order enforceable pending appeal. When granting termination, it also sets the date for possession. An omitted ground cannot simply be added later.

Rescission for breach is separate from notice

Section 6:265 DCC provides a remedy for breach for both Section 230a and Section 290 leases. In all the circumstances, the breach must be serious enough to justify rescission and its consequences. Default may also be required where performance remains possible. Rescission of a lease of built premises for the tenant’s breach requires a court order (Section 7:231 DCC). Specific statutory exceptions include certain administrative closures under the Municipalities Act, Opium Act or Housing Act (Woningwet), and the defects situation in Section 7:210 DCC.

Rescission ends the lease; eviction ends actual occupation. Both can be claimed in proceedings on the merits. A provisional relief judge can order the tenant to leave urgently but cannot rescind the lease. Such an order therefore does not itself terminate the contract. A landlord enforcing provisional possession risks liability if it proves unjustified in the subsequent proceedings. There is no fixed six-month period for proceedings on the merits.

Three months’ rent arrears is an important practical indicator, not an automatic threshold. Clearing arrears, a long trouble-free relationship and temporary financial problems are relevant. A pattern of late payment can remain significant after payment. For nuisance, unauthorised use, subletting or drugs, the court likewise assesses the specific seriousness and circumstances. Recorded complaints and responses matter, including where the tenant structurally fails to address nuisance in time. Demonstrable improvement may make a difference.

Defects: statutory rights and contractual exclusions

Sections 7:204-7:210 DCC start with the enjoyment the tenant could expect from a well-maintained property of the same kind. An interference not attributable to the tenant may be a defect, including leakage, structural problems or faulty installations. The ability to reach and enter the property, and its appearance, can also form part of the expected enjoyment; this does not guarantee visitor numbers or turnover (Supreme Court 27 April 2012, paras 3.4.2-3.4.5).

Factual disturbance by third parties without a claim of right falls outside the definition of a defect. A landlord’s own failure calls for a separate assessment, for example where action could and should be taken against serious nuisance from another tenant of the same landlord. Traffic noise or nuisance alone therefore does not establish a landlord’s breach.

At the tenant’s request, the landlord must remedy defects unless this is impossible or the expenditure cannot reasonably be required. Minor repairs and defects for which the tenant is liable are excluded. If the landlord is in default in carrying out repairs, the tenant can incur reasonable repair costs and set them off against rent; this right cannot be excluded (Section 7:206 DCC).

Section 7:207 DCC allows a proportionate rent reduction from proper notification, or sufficient knowledge on the landlord’s part, until repair. Section 7:208 DCC imposes additional conditions for consequential loss: a later defect must be attributable to the landlord, or an initial defect was known, should have been known, or contradicted an assurance that it was absent. Failure to perform the repair duty can also matter. A defect therefore does not automatically justify recovery of every loss.

ROZ terms often restrict rent reduction and consequential damages, but the model, version and exceptions must be read. Section 7:209 DCC prevents provisions detrimental to the tenant for defects the landlord knew or should have known about when contracting. Section 6:248(2) DCC can also prevent reliance on an exclusion. Known roof problems and water damage to sensitive equipment did not therefore leave the landlord immune (Gelderland District Court 2022, paras 5.6 and 5.16).

The general COVID-19 closure of public-facing Section 290 premises was not a defect, the Supreme Court held. Leases concluded before 15 March 2020 could nevertheless involve unforeseen circumstances under Section 6:258 DCC. Later contracts require individual assessment. The starting point was equal allocation of the relevant loss not already compensated by fixed-cost support (TVL), with room for adjustment. This was not an automatic 50 per cent rent reduction (Supreme Court 24 December 2021, paras 3.2.6 and 3.3.2-3.5.5).

Service charges: contract, evidence and allocation

The residential regime in Section 7:259 DCC, including statutory settlement rules and the Rent Tribunal, does not apply to commercial premises. Section 7:264 DCC on unreasonable advantages also concerns residential leases. For commercial space, the agreement determines the services, which payments are advances, how costs are allocated and when accounts are settled. Contractual interpretation and reasonableness and fairness limit recovery.

ROZ terms address many of these points. The terms in the Gelderland case required an annual itemised statement showing calculation and the tenant’s share, generally within twelve months after the service-charge year. The applicable version and exceptions always matter. Several contracts provide for a five per cent administration charge; it is not a statutory entitlement and does not justify duplicate management charges.

Distinguish day-to-day use and management from major maintenance, replacement and owner’s expenses. Passing on costs requires a contractual basis; commercial lease law does not prohibit every charge for an owner’s expense. An owners’ association invoice cannot therefore simply be passed on in full. Each item requires checking against the allocation of responsibilities and whether it has already been charged elsewhere.

Vacancy also depends on the agreed allocation. The ROZ provision examined by the court prohibited increasing the tenant’s share above that payable at full occupancy. The landlord failed to follow it and insufficiently substantiated the disputed costs (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2010, paras 3.17-3.21). Different wording requires separate assessment; the judgment does not establish a general statutory prohibition on every other arrangement.

A party claiming payment must substantiate its account when it is specifically disputed. A tenant can seek a breakdown and, where appropriate, inspection under the contract and the circumstances. Missing documents do not automatically require repayment of all advances: what was contractually and actually due must first be determined. An estimate or advance is not necessarily a cap on costs.

The settlement system and allocation key are distinct. In Gelderland, switching to definitive monthly accounts required individual written consent under this contract. A turnover-based allocation was permitted because the contract left a reasonable allocation to the landlord (Gelderland District Court 2025, paras 4.4.4 and 4.5.5). In another case, explanation, absence of objection and payment together established acceptance of a revised allocation (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2009, paras 4.3-4.7; appeal in cassation dismissed: Supreme Court 7 October 2011, para. 3).

Years without invoicing do not automatically extinguish a contractual entitlement. Retrospective recovery of an additional fire-insurance premium was nevertheless unacceptable where the tenant could not know its amount or allow for it in running the business. The premium was payable in principle from March 2011. Under the terms, it fell into a category separate from service charges (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2015, paras 3.9 and 3.14-3.17).

Check whether costs were incurred, fall within the contractual category and are reasonably allocated. There is no general statutory requirement to obtain competing quotes for every service. Fixed fees must also be distinguished from advances subject to reconciliation. Mistake was rejected where annual costs rose from €38,748 to €109,368: no cap was agreed, the original estimate was not shown to be inaccurate and services had subsequently expanded (Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal 2019, paras 4.5-4.12).

What should landlords and tenants record before contracting?

Record the agreed use, term and renewal arrangements, the property’s condition and responsibilities for defects. For service charges, specify services, calculation, supporting documents and the settlement period. Broad terms or a security deposit do not replace substantiation. A dispute first requires clarity about whether it concerns termination, postponed possession, repairs or accounts. Enforcement by a mortgagee raises another question: a letting clause does not automatically hold against existing tenants.

Frequently asked questions

How do Section 230a and Section 290 premises differ?

For Section 230a premises such as offices, the lease can end under statute and contract, followed by possible temporary postponement of possession. Section 290 premises such as shops and hospitality venues have additional rules on duration and termination. Without the tenant’s written consent, landlord termination generally requires a court decision. The agreed use determines the regime.

Are three months’ rent arrears enough for rescission?

Three months is an important practical indicator, not an automatic rule. The court assesses seriousness, earlier payment problems, cleared arrears and other circumstances. Provisional possession also requires urgency. Payment before the hearing may therefore matter, while a pattern of late payment can remain relevant even after the arrears have been cleared.

Can a tenant with ROZ terms seek a rent reduction?

Read the particular exclusion and its exceptions. Section 7:209 DCC limits freedom of contract for defects known, or which should have been known, to the landlord at the outset. Reasonableness and fairness can also prevent reliance on a clause. Adjustment for unforeseen COVID-19 measures is a separate route, outside the defects regime.

Cited case law

Supreme Court

Courts of appeal

District courts

See also