Classifying commercial premises: storage or shop?
A car dealer could not claim the statutory protection of shop premises for a rented storage/showroom unit. The Hague Court of Appeal found no agreed sales purpose or later change to it. Years of permitted car sales were insufficient. The judgment shows how the contract, fit-out and evidence of use together determine the lease regime.
Car dealer cannot claim shop-premises protection
The tenant had rented commercial premises in Rotterdam since December 2002, close to a building he owned. New landlords gave notice ending the lease on 30 November 2020. He invoked the protection of Section 290 premises. After possession was given up in 2021, the proceedings on the merits still concerned the validity of termination. The court confirmed that the Section 230a regime applied (The Hague Court of Appeal 2025, paras 3.2-3.17 and 6.25).
The 2002 lease expressly states in its heading "not pursuant to Section 7A:1624 (old) DCC" (now Section 7:290 DCC). The designated-use clause limits use to "storage/showroom space for motor vehicles". Repairs, damage repair and the storage of environmentally hazardous substances are expressly prohibited. The contract says nothing about the sale of cars.
The tenant argues that he sold cars from the premises from the outset, with the landlord's knowledge. He submits statements from a customer, a neighbour and a local resident confirming that car sales took place. In 2013 the landlord even wrote: "we have always allowed you to sell cars from the very beginning."
Court distinguishes tolerated sales from an agreed sales purpose
The court examined the use agreed at the outset, taking the fit-out into account. The contractual label was evidence for interpretation, rather than an independent exclusion of mandatory protection. The wording, the original landlord’s statement and the fit-out gave insufficient support for an agreed sales outlet. Storage and display under Section 7:230a DCC had been agreed (The Hague Court of Appeal 2025, paras 6.2-6.11).
Different actual use does not automatically change the regime. The parties must consent to a change of designated use. Implied consent is possible, but passivity or mere toleration is insufficient. In these circumstances, the court read the 2013 letter as tolerating sales, rather than changing the agreed purpose. The contractual requirement for written consent also mattered (The Hague Court of Appeal 2025, paras 6.15-6.16).
For completeness, the court considered a dual purpose. The predominant use of this particular unit would then matter. Documents about the car business’s overall sales and turnover did not establish that this unit was mainly a sales outlet. The Chamber of Commerce entry included the unit, but did not sufficiently identify where trading took place. Advertisements and sales records linked to this address were also lacking (The Hague Court of Appeal 2025, paras 6.17-6.22).
What should tenants and landlords record about use?
Record the intended use at the outset: storage and display alone, or sales from premises accessible to the public. When permitting different activities later, clarify whether the agreed purpose is also changing. That helps avoid a dispute over the Section 290 regime. Neither the contract’s title nor an isolated Chamber of Commerce entry determines that question.
The tenant also owed €5,000 in penalty payments. These followed from the condition in which the premises were handed back and the late return of keys under the earlier possession order, rather than classification as Section 230a premises itself (The Hague Court of Appeal 2025, paras 6.29-6.35). This enforcement aspect also arises in the article on penalty clauses in leases. Other property topics appear under Real Estate & Construction.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between Section 7:290 and Section 7:230a commercial premises?
Section 7:290 DCC protects, among others, shops, hospitality venues and craft businesses with a sales area accessible to the public against termination. Section 7:230a DCC applies to other built premises, such as offices and storage units. There, temporary protection against eviction can outlast the lease. The agreed purpose and fit-out determine which regime applies.
Can actual use for sales change the rental regime?
It can, if the parties also agree a different designated use; actual use alone is insufficient. Consent may be implied in some circumstances. Here, the letter permitting sales and the actual activities did not establish that change. The contract also required prior written consent to a change of designated use.
How is predominant use established in the case of a mixed designation?
In this case, the court examined the predominant use of the particular unit let to the tenant. That requires concrete indications: sales invoices, advertisements bearing the address, and a fit-out that points to sales. An accountant's statement about the company's total turnover is insufficient if it is not established which premises generated that turnover.
Cited case law
- The Hague Court of Appeal 2 September 2025, ECLI:NL:GHDHA:2025:1854: the agreed purpose determined the regime; tolerated sales did not change it here, and predominant sales use was insufficiently substantiated (paras 6.2 and 6.15-6.22).