Camera surveillance between neighbours and the right to privacy
Two neighbours in Amsterdam had each mounted a camera on their home and each demanded the other's removal. The judge in interim relief proceedings sided with only one of them. On 28 July 2026 the Court of Appeal in Amsterdam drew the line on both sides: both cameras make an unjustified intrusion into the other's privacy and must come down.
Amsterdam neighbours each demand removal of the other's camera
In 2024 one neighbour placed a camera at the rear of her home, one floor up, behind a window. That camera can move and can be steered in every direction from an app on her phone. It captures a large part of her back garden and part of the public road.
Her neighbours mounted a camera on their front facade, aimed at the public road and angled towards her home. That camera can be pointed left, forwards or right and cannot be operated remotely. Demands went back and forth in September and December 2024, without result.
On 19 November 2024 the judge in interim relief proceedings at the District Court of Amsterdam ordered only the neighbour to remove her camera and dismissed her counterclaim. On appeal the court upheld that order, but set aside the dismissal of the counterclaim and ordered the neighbours to remove their camera as well, on pain of a penalty of EUR 100 per day up to a maximum of EUR 1,000.
The court applies a two-step test: intrusion and justification
The court sets out the framework at para. 6.2. In principle anyone may place a camera to protect their own plot, their own home or their own property on the public road. That freedom is limited by the privacy of others: a camera may in principle not capture, or be capable of capturing, the neighbour's plot, home or person. Under settled case law an intrusion into private life is in principle a tortious act, unless a ground of justification removes that character. Whether such a ground exists follows from weighing the seriousness of the intrusion against the interests served by the camera (Supreme Court, 18 April 2014, para. 5.2.1).
At the first step, the court finds a privacy intrusion plausible on the basis of the actual settings and images. The neighbour admitted that her camera moves, resets once a month and then actually turns, and that she can steer it in any direction through the app. Her assertion that the mounting made further movement towards the neighbours' plot impossible was insufficiently explained. That made it sufficiently plausible that the camera captures that plot or is capable of doing so (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2026, para. 6.4). The fact that the camera happened to be pointed elsewhere at a given moment therefore does not save it.
Whoever mounts the camera must explain what it records
At the second step both justifications fail on substantiation. The neighbour argued that she wanted to protect her plot, her belongings and her cats. The court accepts that interest, but she did not explain why the camera had to hang one floor up rather than at ground level, below the height of the fence (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2026, para. 6.5). The defect lies in the position chosen, not in the camera itself.
For the neighbours the issue is the burden of pleading. They claimed their camera captured only their two cars, but did not substantiate that. The court holds at para. 6.8 that it was for them to do so, because only they can show what their camera records. They had moreover argued that the camera helped prevent situations with their neighbour and rebut her statements, which sits badly with a field of view limited to two cars. Their interest in protecting the cars did not require capturing more than those cars (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2026, para. 6.9).
The decisions discussed address that evidence through different legal routes. Where the Court of Appeal in Amsterdam reasons through tort, the sub-district court in Midden-Nederland assessed a comparable mutual dispute under the GDPR and placed the burden of pleading and proof expressly on the party processing the images (Central Netherlands District Court 2026, para. 4.12). In a case where the camera also served several neighbours’ safety, the District Court of Gelderland held that its use was not purely household activity, and ordered the camera to be turned rather than removed (Gelderland District Court 2024). The legal bases differ, but both assessments consider the security interest, the necessity of the intrusion and less intrusive alternatives.
What does this mean for anyone mounting a camera on their facade?
Where there is a privacy intrusion, the camera’s position and settings matter. The availability of a lower position, a narrower field of view or shielding that still serves the security purpose is relevant. A movable or remotely operated camera may create additional risks: in the Central Netherlands District Court case of 2023 the judge expressly prohibited reinstalling a movable camera, while a fixed camera at the front was allowed to remain.
Anyone wishing to keep their camera must be able to demonstrate what it records. That succeeded in the Gelderland District Court case of 2025, where the owner used privacy masks and a bailiff drew up a record of findings: the security cameras survived the test and the residual intrusion by the doorbell cameras was held to be justified by the safety interest. In that case, the mere possibility of changing settings later was insufficient to establish unlawfulness; there were no concrete indications of such use. Shielding is therefore no automatic guarantee, and technical adjustability does not automatically require removal.
It also pays to bring the counterclaim straight away. The Amsterdam Court of Appeal did not regard the counterclaim as prematurely brought and considered it urgent by its nature (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2026, para. 6.7), so the neighbour secured her remedy in interim relief proceedings after all.
Frequently asked questions
May a camera film part of the public road?
Not without more. Once the camera captures identifiable individuals, the question is whether the owner's interest outweighs the intrusion. In this case it counted against the neighbours that the footage showed their neighbour entering and leaving her home or car, which goes beyond guarding two parked cars.
Is a camera that does not record also unlawful?
That depends on what is made plausible. Not storing images does not mean there can be no intrusion: live images may also affect privacy. Based on the actual images and adjustment options, the court found it plausible that the camera captured or could capture the neighbours’ plot. Where it could not be established that a camera worked or was switched on, it was allowed to remain, as in the 2023 decision of the District Court of Midden-Nederland.
Does the GDPR apply to a camera on a private home?
It depends on the use. The exemption covers purely personal or household activities. Surveillance also directed at public space or other properties may fall outside it. Where the GDPR applies and the owner relies on legitimate interests, Article 6(1)(f) GDPR requires necessity and a balancing of interests, including proportionality and subsidiarity. Privacy rights also remain relevant outside the GDPR.
Court of Appeal of Amsterdam, 28 July 2026, ECLI:NL:GHAMS:2026:2101
Cited case law
Supreme Court
- Supreme Court 18 April 2014, ECLI:NL:HR:2014:942: an intrusion into private life is in principle unlawful; justification requires balancing the concrete interests and seriousness of the intrusion. The case concerned a personal investigation by an insurer (para. 5.2.1).
Courts of Appeal
- Amsterdam Court of Appeal 28 July 2026, ECLI:NL:GHAMS:2026:2101: the cameras’ actual positions and adjustment options made a privacy intrusion plausible; substantiation of necessity and field of view was insufficient (paras. 6.2–6.9).
District Courts
- Midden-Nederland District Court 12 March 2026, ECLI:NL:RBMNE:2026:905: in this GDPR assessment, the burden of pleading and proving compliance rested on the party processing the camera images (paras. 4.11–4.13).
- Gelderland District Court 24 December 2025, ECLI:NL:RBGEL:2025:11492: privacy masks and recorded observations substantiated the limited fields of view; the slight, temporary intrusion by doorbell cameras was justified here (paras. 4.5–4.10).
- The Hague District Court 16 December 2025, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2025:24055: the safety interest did not outweigh the intrusion given the doorbell camera’s position, recording and storage options, and the alternatives available (paras. 4.4–4.9).
- Gelderland District Court 26 June 2024, ECLI:NL:RBGEL:2024:9879: the camera also served several neighbours and fell outside the household exemption in this case; its excessively wide field of view had to be adjusted (paras. 1.4–1.10).
- Midden-Nederland District Court 10 August 2023, ECLI:NL:RBMNE:2023:4181: the movable camera overlooking the neighbouring home had to go; the other camera was not shown to be working, and an intrusion was not established (paras. 4.4–4.9).
- Zeeland-West-Brabant District Court 17 December 2025, ECLI:NL:RBZWB:2025:9022: protection of property is balanced against privacy in the home and garden, with attention to less intrusive camera positions (paras. 4.2–4.5, 4.9–4.11).