When the repair bill can be reduced
A deduction for betterment, known in Dutch practice as aftrek nieuw voor oud, means that a seller or contractor need not pay part of the repair bill because something new replaces something old. Two conditions apply: the injured party must in fact derive a benefit, and it must be reasonable to bring that benefit into account. It is commonly calculated by dividing the age of the item replaced by its useful life.
A caution on the Dutch name. Nieuw voor oud translates literally as "new for old", but in English insurance practice a new-for-old policy pays the replacement cost precisely without a deduction for betterment. The Dutch phrase therefore means close to the opposite of the English term of the same words.
Four questions determine the outcome of a dispute of this kind, and they are addressed below in turn:
- Is there an actual benefit?
- Does the contract provide for a deduction for betterment?
- Which head of loss does the benefit attach to?
- How is that benefit evidenced and quantified?
Why one case produced three different deductions
On 4 January 2023 the Rotterdam District Court awarded the buyers of a farmhouse €25,592.70 in total, split across three heads of loss with three deductions: 0%, 50% and 17.5% (Rotterdam District Court 2023, para. 2.25). One case, three outcomes; the explanation is the key to the whole subject.
During earlier building work a load-bearing roof beam had been sawn through to make room for a rooflight (Rotterdam District Court 2023, para. 2.4). By the time the buyers discovered it, the house was at risk of collapse; the walls had to be shored up and a new concrete foundation poured.
For the roof structure itself the court made no deduction: it is "an essential part of the house, which must be present and in sound condition", so repairing the missing parts confers no benefit (Rotterdam District Court 2023, para. 2.12).
The foundation was treated differently: that head of loss was halved, from €25,303.33 to €12,651.66. The foundation was, admittedly, needed to prevent collapse, "but the house ended up with a far better foundation than the house the claimants originally bought" (Rotterdam District Court 2023, para. 2.17). The court also took into account that before the purchase the buyers had already been alerted to a potential cost for cracks and the foundation, which "must be regarded as having been at least partly reflected in the purchase price" (Rotterdam District Court 2023, para. 2.18).
The floor insulation was the only head on which the court actually did the arithmetic. The seller had disclosed only that insulation was present, not when it had been installed (Rotterdam District Court 2023, para. 2.22). The court took as its reference point the seller's own belief that the insulation dated from 2012, which would have made it 7 years old at the date of the purchase. Against a 40-year useful life that gives 17.5%, and the deduction applied to the demolition and groundworks as well, because those costs "would have had to be incurred in any event in order to replace the floor insulation" (Rotterdam District Court 2023, para. 2.23).
1. Does the repair confer an actual benefit?
The Supreme Court answered the central question on 23 June 2023, in a case about a damaged water main. May part of reasonable repair costs be deducted as a benefit under Section 6:100 of the Dutch Civil Code (DCC)? The Supreme Court held that it may. The argument that nothing can be brought into account where loss has been assessed on an objective basis rests on "an incorrect view of the law" (Supreme Court 23 June 2023, para. 3.3.1) and cannot stand. The Supreme Court does not itself use the expression nieuw voor oud; it is used in the opinion of Advocate General Lindenbergh, who describes the doctrine as "expenditure forced upon the injured party" (Advocate General Lindenbergh 2 December 2022, para. 4.17).
That is balanced by a limit which protects the injured party. In assessing what is reasonable, "regard must be had, among other things, to the need to avoid forcing a particular pattern of expenditure on the injured party against his will" (Supreme Court 23 June 2023, para. 3.2). In that case the deduction of 30% could not stand, because the court of appeal had given insufficient reasons for it (Supreme Court 23 June 2023, para. 3.3.2).
The Amsterdam Court of Appeal applied that test in the context of a house purchase on 9 January 2024. The buyer had to replace the whole roof structure, which was damaged by damp and fungal decay. The court refused the deduction and awarded €51,083.34 (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2024, para. 3.25). The decisive factor was that the buyer had had no apparent intention of replacing the roof and had to borrow to pay for it. That the new roof is better "is inherent in the fact that the roof simply had to be replaced in its entirety" (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2024, para. 3.24).
Where the repair demonstrably extends the useful life, a deduction may follow, and the fraction set out at the start of this article comes into play. Extension of life is not by itself enough to make a deduction reasonable. The Zeeland-West-Brabant District Court put the useful life of roof shingles at 25 years, and the covering replaced was 8 years old, producing a deduction of one third (Zeeland-West-Brabant District Court 2026, paras 2.9 and 2.10).
Useful life is the most common form of benefit, but not the only one. In a roof replacement the East Brabant District Court considered three interrelated factors: betterment, energy savings and an increase in value (East Brabant District Court 2023, para. 2.2(b)). Elsewhere a benefit remained even after the useful-life deduction had been disallowed, on account of lower maintenance costs and a slightly better resale value. A party who argues only about age therefore overlooks other heads of benefit.
The converse is just as instructive. On 27 September 2022 the 's-Hertogenbosch Court of Appeal refused a contractual deduction in a case about damp. The repair was needed to make the house fit for normal use, and the court added: "Since only localised repair is involved, it will have no appreciable effect on when the roof will need replacing" (’s-Hertogenbosch Court of Appeal 2022, para. 3.4.20). Repair that does not defer the replacement date therefore gives rise to no benefit to bring into account.
Against what baseline is the comparison made? That question drives the outcome, and it is answered differently depending on whether the claim arises under a sale or under a contract for work. On a sale the point of comparison is what the purchase agreement promised, which is an old but sound component: the East Brabant District Court held that the buyer was entitled to "a sound 40-year-old roof" (East Brabant District Court 2023, para. 2.2(b)).
Under a contract for work the point of comparison is proper performance, and the lapse of time is then decisive. If the defect comes to light quickly, the client would have had the same new component in any event. As the Gelderland District Court put it: "Had the defendant carried out his work properly, the claimant would equally have had a new, insulated and watertight roof" (Gelderland District Court 2024, para. 4.5). If the client has had the benefit of the defective work for years, those years do count: for roof covering laid in 2010 and replaced in 2025, the Overijssel District Court reduced the client's award by 14/35ths, reflecting 14 years of a 35-year life (Overijssel District Court 2025, para. 5.60).
2. What difference does a contractual clause make?
In the judgments considered here, a deduction on a sale of property usually rests on the purchase agreement itself. Clause 6.3 of the model agreement published by the Dutch estate agents' association (NVM) provides: "For defects which prevent normal use and which the buyer neither knew of nor could reasonably have discovered at the date of this agreement, the seller is liable only for the cost of repair. In assessing the cost of repair, account is taken of the deduction for betterment."
In the case decided by the Central Netherlands District Court on 10 August 2022 this was the 2018 NVM model agreement for an existing house (Central Netherlands District Court 2022, para. 2.1). The clause recurs in the judgments considered here in the same wording, but always check the agreement itself, because the text differs from edition to edition.
That changes where the argument starts. With such a clause a deduction is more readily applied, and several judgments show that courts sometimes assess the amount themselves where the parties provide too little material to work from.
The Central Netherlands District Court said as much: "Since neither party has specified what the deduction should be, the subdistrict court will determine it." It proceeded on the basis of a roof with a life of at least 40 years which was 17 years old at completion, and arrived at 50% (Central Netherlands District Court 2022, para. 4.6). Elsewhere the deduction was assessed "as a matter of estimate and reasonableness" at 10% after the sellers named no figure and the buyers pointed only to their invoice (North Holland District Court 2022, para. 4.24).
In the absence of such a clause the bar is higher, because the defendant must then plead and evidence the benefit. The District Court of The Hague accepted that newly installed components last longer (The Hague District Court 2017, para. 4.34) and still rejected the argument, because no actual benefit had been established (The Hague District Court 2017, para. 4.35). An argument based on extended useful life therefore needs both evidence of that extension and a figure for it.
Courts depart from a contractual starting point where no benefit exists. The 's-Hertogenbosch Court of Appeal refused the deduction in the damp case even though it had been agreed. On 28 January 2026 the Limburg District Court did the same, "since the claimants were not required to anticipate the roof being of such poor quality, given the 2021 renovation" (Limburg District Court 2026, para. 4.38). The same court did apply the deduction on 19 March 2025 in a case about a wet cellar, holding that the buyer could not challenge it as unreasonable because it was "simply part of the agreement concluded with the defendants" (Limburg District Court 2025, para. 2.5).
The clause therefore provides a starting point, but the substantive test still has to be satisfied.
3. Which head of loss is subject to the deduction?
Courts sometimes determine the deduction head by head and sometimes apply it to the whole claim. Where the heads of loss differ in nature, that division can determine the outcome. That apportionment reflects the direction in Section 6:97 DCC to assess loss in the manner most consistent with its nature, and that nature differs from element to element.
The contrast is sharpest outside residential property. Where a cherry picker had been driven across tennis courts, the Rotterdam District Court awarded the full cost of the drainage system, because it would not have needed replacing but for that incident (Rotterdam District Court 2021, para. 4.14), and made an 80% deduction from the cost of the top layer because the playing surfaces were "towards the end of their useful life" (Rotterdam District Court 2021, para. 4.24). One event, two heads of loss, two outcomes.
The same approach applies to residential property. In the wet cellar case the Limburg District Court made a 65% deduction from the plasterwork and none from the waterproofing itself, because the buyers "were entitled to expect in any event that the cellars would be watertight" (Limburg District Court 2025, para. 2.8.2).
In the Zeeland case about the roof shingles the deduction applied to the roof renovation only, while the full cost of the window frames was awarded (Zeeland-West-Brabant District Court 2026, paras 2.7 and 2.10). The point arose on appeal to the Supreme Court as well: it held that the court of appeal had failed to explain why the deduction should also cover "the element of the loss represented by the cost of preventing further damage" (Supreme Court 23 June 2023, para. 3.3.2).
Once the deduction attaches, it reaches beyond the material replaced. In the Rotterdam case the deduction on the floor insulation carried the demolition and groundworks with it. On 9 July 2025 the Central Netherlands District Court held: "Contrary to what the claimants contend, the deduction for betterment must also be applied to the cost of labour." The reason is that when carrying out maintenance later, the owner would have had to pay his contractor for labour in any event (Central Netherlands District Court 2025, para. 2.13).
4. How is the benefit evidenced and calculated?
The figures warrant some caution. The occasional judgment applies the formula directly, as the Gelderland District Court did for a conservatory 9 years into a useful life of 20 years: 45% (Gelderland District Court 2024, para. 4.13). Far more often the court arrives at a round percentage "in fairness" or "by estimation". In a case arising out of a collision between vessels, the Court of Appeal of The Hague went further. The dates on which the old and new coatings were applied do not form the basis for the deduction: that view "is wrong in law", principally because it is not the statutory test (The Hague Court of Appeal 2022, para. 5.12).
Work out the fraction and advance it in the alternative. Without a substantiated figure, the court has greater room to estimate. In the Central Netherlands roof case the subdistrict court took 17 of 40 years and rounded the resulting 42.5% up to 50%. In the North Holland case it assessed 10% by estimation, neither party having named a figure.
Consider whether the other side has made out its case. In the absence of a contractual clause it must identify the actual benefit and express it in money. If it relies on an extension of useful life, the normal useful life and the years already elapsed are relevant. A reference to a supplier's website has been held insufficient, and in the case before it the Amsterdam Court of Appeal required evidence of the increase in the property's value, corrected for the general movement of the property market. Other judgments are content with a useful-life or maintenance approach without valuing the whole house.
What should a buyer of a defective house do?
Record the condition of the defective component before it is replaced. After demolition, its age and wear may be difficult to establish. Photographs, a surveyor’s report and a quotation itemised by component provide a basis for doing so.
Where a great deal turns on it and demolition is necessary, consider applying for a preliminary court-appointed expert’s report and invite the other side in writing to the inspection. An expert can provide better evidence of the technical need for repair and its extent than a quotation alone.
Then split the claim into heads of loss and consider for each head whether the repair extends the useful life. Structural components that ought to be sound in any event more often than not escape a deduction; where a component has a replacement cycle of its own, such as roof covering, insulation or building services, a deduction may be justified. Work that was needed only to gain access to the defect follows the head of loss to which it belongs.
If the purchase agreement provides for a deduction for betterment, a deduction is more readily applied, but an actual benefit is still required. There are three ways round the clause: that there is no benefit, as in the Limburg roof case and the 's-Hertogenbosch damp case; that the clause does not extend to this head of loss; or that the buyer is not bound by it.
That last route has to be raised expressly. In the cellar case the objection failed on exactly that point: the deduction was part of the agreement "and nothing has been pleaded or proved to show why the claimants are not bound by that term" (Limburg District Court 2025, para. 2.5). It is therefore not enough for a buyer to say the clause is unreasonable, but the door is not closed.
Consider whether the other side is insured. In a case about a farmhouse destroyed by fire the North Holland District Court held that bringing a benefit into account is "hardly ever reasonable" where the event falls under the defendant's liability insurance, referring to the legislature's intention underlying Section 6:100 DCC (North Holland District Court 2021, para. 4.7). That is a possible argument rather than a general exclusion, and whether it succeeds depends on the circumstances. The point arises mainly in tort, and against a contractor carrying public liability insurance. It rarely arises against a private seller, because a standard personal liability policy does not extend to contractual liability for a defective house.
Finally, do not let the claim drift. In the Rotterdam farmhouse case the buyers were entitled to wait for the outcome of the proceedings and the court worked from the most recent quotation (Rotterdam District Court 2023, para. 2.11); in the Limburg motorhome case the price increase fell on the injured party after 3 years of inaction (Limburg District Court 2025, para. 4.21). More on the steps leading up to such a claim is set out in the analysis of hidden defects after buying a home.
Frequently asked questions
Can the deduction exceed half?
Yes. The judgments discussed include an 80% deduction for a worn artificial grass surface and 65% for plasterwork. The percentage depends on the actual benefit and whether the deduction is reasonable. A high percentage therefore needs evidence of the condition and remaining useful life of the component replaced.
Does the deduction apply to labour as well as materials?
Labour may also be included: the owner would have paid installation costs on a later replacement too. The Central Netherlands District Court held this on 9 July 2025 (para. 2.13). The Gelderland judgment discussed there limited the deduction to materials because of its particular facts. An itemised quotation makes that distinction possible.
May the court apply the deduction without the other side asking for it?
The safer view is that the deduction must be raised and substantiated as a defence. The Supreme Court requires regard to the parties’ arguments (8 July 2016, para. 4.4.5). A motorhome judgment recording no separate defence does not provide sufficient grounds to rely on the court applying the deduction of its own motion.
Cited case law
Supreme Court
- Supreme Court, 23 June 2023, ECLI:NL:HR:2023:956: benefits may be brought into account even against objectively assessed repair costs; reasonableness and adequate reasons remain essential (paras 3.2-3.3.2).
- Supreme Court, 8 July 2016, ECLI:NL:HR:2016:1483: for a passing-on defence, a benefit may be considered in assessing loss or under Section 6:100 DCC, within the parties’ arguments (paras 4.4.1-4.4.5).
Advocate General’s opinions
- Opinion of Advocate General Lindenbergh, 2 December 2022, ECLI:NL:PHR:2022:1132: betterment may involve forced expenditure; actual benefit and the need for caution require attention (para. 4.17).
Courts of appeal
- Amsterdam Court of Appeal, 9 January 2024, ECLI:NL:GHAMS:2024:54: no deduction for necessary replacement of an entire roof which the buyer had not planned and had to borrow to fund (paras 3.24-3.25).
- ’s-Hertogenbosch Court of Appeal, 27 September 2022, ECLI:NL:GHSHE:2022:3269: no contractual deduction for localised repair without substantial benefit or an appreciable delay to replacement (para. 3.4.20).
- The Hague Court of Appeal, 28 June 2022, ECLI:NL:GHDHA:2022:1850: age data alone do not constitute the statutory test for bringing a benefit into account (para. 5.12).
District courts
- Zeeland-West-Brabant District Court, 4 February 2026, ECLI:NL:RBZWB:2026:662: a one-third deduction for eight-year-old roof covering with an estimated useful life of 25 years (paras 2.9-2.10).
- Limburg District Court, 28 January 2026, ECLI:NL:RBLIM:2026:783: no deduction for a roof whose poor condition the buyers were not required to anticipate after a recent renovation (para. 4.38).
- Overijssel District Court, 3 September 2025, ECLI:NL:RBOVE:2025:5429: a 40% deduction for reduced maintenance, longer practical useful life and increased value after roof replacement. (Overijssel District Court 2025, para. 5.60).
- Limburg District Court, 23 July 2025, ECLI:NL:RBLIM:2025:7641: in this motorhome case, the injured party bore the price increase after delaying repair for three years (para. 4.21).
- Central Netherlands District Court, 9 July 2025, ECLI:NL:RBMNE:2025:3523: the deduction included labour because later maintenance would also have involved labour costs (para. 2.13).
- Limburg District Court, 19 March 2025, ECLI:NL:RBLIM:2025:8668: the agreed deduction applied to plasterwork (65%) but not to making the cellar watertight (paras 2.5 and 2.8.2).
- Gelderland District Court, 10 April 2024, ECLI:NL:RBGEL:2024:1960: a 45% deduction for a nine-year-old conservatory with an estimated useful life of twenty years (para. 4.13).
- Zeeland-West-Brabant District Court, 21 February 2024, ECLI:NL:RBZWB:2024:1080: an estimated 50% deduction for new components and labour in a 1995 motorhome (para. 4.19).
- Gelderland District Court, 31 January 2024, ECLI:NL:RBGEL:2024:485: no deduction under a contract for work where proper performance would have produced the same new, insulated and watertight roof. (Gelderland District Court 2024, para. 4.5).
- East Brabant District Court, 20 September 2023, ECLI:NL:RBOBR:2023:4991: a new roof, energy savings and increased value together supported one estimated deduction of 40% (para. 2.2(b)(v)).
- Rotterdam District Court, 4 January 2023, ECLI:NL:RBROT:2023:542: no deduction for roof-structure repair, 50% for improved foundations and 17.5% for floor insulation and associated work (paras 2.12, 2.17-2.23).
- Central Netherlands District Court, 10 August 2022, ECLI:NL:RBMNE:2022:3469: the court estimated the contractual deduction when neither party substantiated a specific percentage (para. 4.6).
- North Holland District Court, 2 March 2022, ECLI:NL:RBNHO:2022:1923: an estimated 10% deduction for a newer, insulated roof where no specific calculation had been provided (para. 4.24).
- North Holland District Court, 8 December 2021, ECLI:NL:RBNHO:2021:11280: liability insurance cover precluded a deduction in this fire case; this is not a general exclusion (para. 4.7).
- Rotterdam District Court, 13 October 2021, ECLI:NL:RBROT:2021:10211: drainage was reimbursed in full, while an 80% deduction applied to the worn artificial grass surface (paras 4.14 and 4.24).
- The Hague District Court, 5 July 2017, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2017:7419: possible maintenance savings were insufficient without sufficiently specific facts supporting the benefit (paras 4.34-4.35).
See also
- Damage to the neighbouring building: careful work is not always enough
- Hidden defects after buying a home: from suspicion to writ of summons
- Age clause in a Dutch house purchase: when does the seller's defence succeed?
- Asbestos after buying a home: who pays for the removal?
- Contractor bankrupt: when is the director personally liable?