Skip to content

The cadastral boundary does not match the fence: who owns the strip of land?

6 August 2026Juriaan de Vries

Property boundaries on the sale and transfer of land

A fence 1.8 metres high stood beside the cadastral boundary, with a strip of roughly 25 m² between them. On 17 July 2026 the Supreme Court upheld the ruling that the plot buyers had acquired that strip too. The judgment shows how the purchase agreement, deed of transfer and visible situation together determine ownership boundaries.

Boundary dispute after the plot was surveyed

Both parcels were held by the same family until 2013. Around 2005 that family put up an iron fence that has every appearance of a boundary fence, but that does not stand on the cadastral boundary. The triangular strip in between, called the "taartpunt" (pie slice) in the pleadings, has since formed part of the garden of the house.

In February 2013 the family sold the building plot behind that fence. The deed of sale states the address, the cadastral designation and the size of 1,185 m2 (11 ares and 85 centiares), to which a cadastral drawing signed by the parties was attached. Transfer followed on 2 April 2013. The house was sold on in 2014 and was acquired by the present neighbours in 2018.

In 2021 the plot buyers had their parcel surveyed for landscaping. The survey showed that the fence did not stand on the cadastral boundary. They wanted to move it to that boundary, the neighbours refused, and both the Oost-Brabant District Court and the 's-Hertogenbosch Court of Appeal ruled in the plot buyers' favour.

Sale and transfer require different standards of interpretation

Besides authority to dispose of the land, its transfer requires a valid legal basis (Section 3:84 DCC) and a registered notarial deed of transfer (Section 3:89 DCC). Here, that legal basis is the purchase agreement. Only land covered by both the sale and the transfer passes to the buyer. The narrower of the two therefore determines the extent (Advocate General Bartels 20 March 2026, paras 4.14-4.15).

The purchase agreement is interpreted under the Haviltex standard: what could the parties reasonably infer from each other’s statements and conduct? The deed of transfer is interpreted objectively, by reference to the intention expressed in it. The cadastral map may provide a point of reference, but there is no statutory presumption that it shows the ownership boundary. The map is not part of the public registers (Advocate General Bartels 20 March 2026, paras 4.8-4.17).

Supreme Court: the deed of sale was a permissible starting point

The appeal in cassation was dismissed. The court of appeal had put the Haviltex standard first, and it was free to begin its interpretation of the contract of sale with the description of the property sold in the deed of sale (Supreme Court 17 July 2026, para. 3.2.3). That description, together with the signed cadastral drawing, produced the provisional conclusion that the parties had the whole cadastral parcel in mind.

The court of appeal then weighed the counter-arguments. The buyers did not know that the fence stood beside the cadastral boundary, and they were buying a building plot. Absent any statement from the sellers to that effect, they did not have to expect that a small part of the parcel fell outside the sale (Supreme Court 17 July 2026, para. 3.2.4).

The complaint about the burden of proof also failed: the court of appeal did not rule on Section 150 DCCP, but on whether a third party may rely on the interpretation of someone else's contract of sale (Supreme Court 17 July 2026, para. 3.1.2). The address in the deed of transfer merely indicates the location (Supreme Court 17 July 2026, para. 3.3.2). What remained is an assessment of the facts, which the Supreme Court reviews only for adequacy of reasoning. The remaining complaints were dismissed under Section 81(1) of the Judiciary Organisation Act (RO).

The Advocate General gave the fence greater weight

The opinion of Advocate General Bartels advised setting the judgment aside and remitting the case. In ordinary transactions between private individuals, he argues, parties primarily rely on what they see on the ground. The legislative history stresses that mapped boundaries should reflect the parties’ understanding. Giving the map great weight may also force them to commission additional surveys (Advocate General Bartels 20 March 2026, paras 4.11-4.12 and 4.30-4.34).

His criticism of the court of appeal concerns two points. First, it took the interests of third parties consulting the public registers into account when interpreting the sale. In the Advocate General’s view, this gave the wording of the deeds too much weight. The objective standard governs the transfer; third parties may also obtain protection, subject to conditions, under Sections 3:26 and 3:88 DCC (Advocate General Bartels 20 March 2026, paras 4.26-4.28 and 4.68-4.70).

Second, the Advocate General considered that the parties’ lack of awareness of the discrepancy could itself point to reliance on the visible fence (Advocate General Bartels 20 March 2026, paras 4.91 and 4.100-4.102). The Supreme Court did not follow his advice to set the judgment aside. It held that the legal-certainty consideration had played no part in the interpretation. The court of appeal was entitled to start with the purchase agreement and had then adequately assessed the other circumstances (Supreme Court 17 July 2026, paras 3.2.3-3.2.6).

What does this mean for buyers of land?

Have an intended boundary along a fence, ditch or line of trees clearly described in both the purchase agreement and the deed of transfer. A sufficiently clear physical description in the deed will generally prevail over a conflicting cadastral designation. An address usually identifies only the location. A signed cadastral drawing may instead support the view that the whole cadastral parcel was intended (Supreme Court 17 July 2026, paras 3.2.3 and 3.3.2).

When interpreting the transfer, the deed therefore provides the basis for departing from the cadastral boundary. The Amsterdam Court of Appeal inferred from the description of the property as agricultural land that the strip with the row of trees and concrete posts fell outside the property transferred. The The Hague Court of Appeal left an allocation drawing (uitgiftetekening) out of account precisely because it had not been attached to the deed. (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2025, para. 4.11); (The Hague Court of Appeal 2025, paras 6.5-6.7).

For the neighbour on the defending side the position is different. He may assert that the acquisition by his opponent lacks a valid title, which is a denial rather than an affirmative defence, but without concrete facts he will not get as far as the taking of evidence. The fence presumption in Section 5:36 DCC also applies only where the fence actually serves to separate the two properties, which the court of appeal did not accept. (Supreme Court 17 July 2026, paras 3.1.2 and 3.4.2).

The court of appeal set aside the possession presumption in Section 3:119 DCC by applying Section 5:47(2) DCC. That is open to question: under the Supreme Court’s judgment of 8 July 2016, judicial determination of a boundary is available only where neither party asserts a particular boundary line, or where the line asserted cannot be proved. The Advocate General noted in a footnote that the court of appeal wrongly treated this case as a boundary determination. That consideration was not challenged in cassation and therefore stands. (Supreme Court 8 July 2016, paras 3.3.2-3.3.3).

Frequently asked questions

Is the cadastral map proof of my boundary?

The map may provide evidence, but does not itself determine ownership. What matters is the land acquired through sale and transfer, potentially supplemented by acquisitive prescription. A Land Registry boundary reconstruction makes the cadastral line visible. There is no statutory presumption that this line is also the ownership boundary.

What if the fence does not stand on the cadastral boundary?

Examine both the purchase agreement and the deed of transfer. Statements and circumstances also matter when interpreting the sale; the objectively interpreted deed governs the transfer. A failure to refer to the fence therefore does not automatically decide the entire dispute. Long-standing use may also raise a separate question of acquisitive prescription.

Can a neighbour rely on a contract of sale between other parties?

Yes. An interested third party may argue that the purchase agreement does not cover the purported transfer, thereby disputing the opponent’s ownership. Specific facts are needed; general assertions do not justify taking evidence. The Supreme Court did not thereby place the burden of proving ownership on the disputing neighbour (17 July 2026, paras 3.1.2 and 3.4.2).

Cited case law

Supreme Court

Advocate General’s opinion

Courts of appeal

District courts

See also