Skip to content

GDPR access request as a business model: when is it an abuse of rights?

16 July 2026Juriaan de Vries

GDPR access requests and abuse of rights

An applicant who requested access from dozens of online retailers and then demanded money had seven applications declared inadmissible for abuse of rights in July 2026. The North Holland decisions show what evidence is needed, when actual legal costs can be recovered and how an online retailer should respond to such a request.

A pattern of requests points to a business model

Anyone who places an order with an online retailer leaves personal data behind. Under Article 15 of the GDPR, the customer may request access to that data without saying why. On 13 July 2026, the District Court of North Holland found in two decisions that this right had been used as a business model. One concerned an online garden furniture retailer (District Court of North Holland 2026, garden furniture retailer), the other a second online retailer (District Court of North Holland 2026, second retailer).

In the case of the second retailer, a customer submitted an access request on 18 July 2025. A little over a month later a letter of demand followed: comply within fourteen days, failing which €925 excluding VAT in extrajudicial costs would be due. Another month later came a non-negotiable settlement proposal of €1,250, under threat of proceedings. On 5 October 2025 the retailer provided general information about the processing and asked the applicant to confirm his identity. There was no response. At the hearing in the proceedings, he reduced his application to access alone, with a penalty payment of €250 per day up to €35,000 (District Court of North Holland 2026, second retailer, paras 2.1-3.2).

The court did not reach the merits. The same applicant had brought about twenty of these cases before the court. At the hearing he stated that he had made some ninety access requests in eighteen months, and comparable cases were also pending before the District Courts of Rotterdam and Central Netherlands. Anyone who refused, or gave too little access, was taken to court. According to the court, the applicant had "deliberately constructed a situation" that was meant to earn him damages (District Court of North Holland 2026, garden furniture retailer, paras 4.16, 4.17 and 4.20). On 13 and 21 July 2026 five further decisions followed against the same applicant, with the same outcome. The decisions discussed here were given at first instance.

Abuse of rights: a high threshold, and the pattern counts

An abuse of rights defence starts with Section 3:13 DCC: a person who abuses a power cannot invoke it. A court does not readily accept this, because everyone must have access to the courts (Article 6 ECHR; District Court of North Holland 2026, garden furniture retailer, para. 4.4). For the right of access, Article 12(5) GDPR provides its own test. The controller may refuse manifestly unfounded or excessive requests, in particular where they are repetitive, and must itself demonstrate that the request is of that kind.

A purpose other than checking one's own data is not in itself sufficient for that. In C-307/22 the Court of Justice held that such a request must also be granted. The Court of Appeal of 's-Hertogenbosch said the same in July 2026 about information someone requests for use in other proceedings. There, additional circumstances turned it into abuse: a former civil servant kept turning to his former municipality with more than a hundred requests "as leverage" to obtain financial compensation, while the information requested did not exist (Court of Appeal of 's-Hertogenbosch 2026, para. 6.9.9).

The Court of Justice clarified the limits on 19 March 2026 in Brillen Rottler (C-526/24). A private individual had signed up for the newsletter of a German optician and requested access thirteen days later. Even a first request of that kind can be excessive, if the controller clearly demonstrates that it was made in order to artificially create the conditions for obtaining damages. All the circumstances are taken into account: whether the data subject provided the data without being obliged to do so, for what purpose, how much time elapsed between providing the data and the request, and how the data subject behaved. Public information about a pattern of requests and damages claims made to other companies may be taken into account, provided that other evidence supports it. The Court interprets the exception strictly; the criteria are demanding (CJEU 19 March 2026, Brillen Rottler, paras 35 and 41-43).

In North Holland, that evidence was available. The same pattern recurred in the seven decisions: costs announced at an early stage, pressure to settle, a claim reduced shortly before or at the hearing, and representatives who did not appear and whose existence was doubted. The applicant was declared inadmissible (District Court of North Holland 2026, garden furniture retailer, para. 4.26). The Administrative Jurisdiction Division of the Council of State ruled the same way in 2022 about someone who asked municipalities for access in order to collect penalty payments afterwards for failure to decide in time.

Actual legal costs must be substantiated

When it came to legal costs, the way the defence was substantiated made the difference. The second retailer appeared in person and was awarded €50 for travel expenses and time lost (District Court of North Holland 2026, second retailer, para. 4.13). The garden furniture retailer had a lawyer, asked for its actual costs and itemised them; there the applicant had to pay €10,105.49, of which €9,181.49 was lawyer's fees (District Court of North Holland 2026, garden furniture retailer, paras 4.27-4.30). Another online retailer was awarded €7,047.97 in the same way (District Court of North Holland 21 July 2026, ECLI:NL:RBNHO:2026:9168, para. 5.13). A retailer that did ask for its actual costs but did not quantify them received costs on the fixed scale only (District Court of North Holland 21 July 2026, ECLI:NL:RBNHO:2026:9165, para. 5.13).

What can online retailers do about an improper GDPR request?

Normally, respond to an access request within one month. Where necessary because of the complexity or number of requests, that period may be extended by two months; notify the applicant within the first month and explain why (Article 12(3) GDPR). A late response may constitute an infringement capable of supporting a damages claim. In North Holland the applicant's pattern was decisive, even against an online retailer that only answered after ten months. There the court assessed the abuse of its own motion, without the retailer having expressly invoked it (District Court of North Holland 21 July 2026, ECLI:NL:RBNHO:2026:9167, paras 2.1, 2.4 and 4.2). That exceptional finding does not give other retailers permission to leave a request unanswered. If the retailer has reason to doubt the identity of the person making the request, it may ask for the information necessary to confirm it (Article 12(6) GDPR), and no more than that.

If the retailer wishes to refuse a request as excessive, it says so within one month, giving the reason and pointing out the possibility of a complaint to the Dutch Data Protection Authority and of proceedings before the courts (Article 12(4) GDPR). Record what points to a pattern: a letter of demand announcing costs shortly after the request, a settlement proposal under threat of proceedings, settlement amounts that keep shifting, and public information about cases against other companies. Do not pay under pressure: the business model relies on companies that, fearing large compensation awards, pay to be rid of the hassle (District Court of North Holland 2026, garden furniture retailer, para. 4.20).

If it comes to proceedings, invoking Article 12(5) GDPR and abuse of rights is the most far-reaching defence: the court then does not reach the merits. Expressly ask for the actual costs of the proceedings and itemise them by hours and rate. Without that explanation, recovery may be limited: where abuse of process was established, only €1,500 of the €3,492.04 excluding VAT claimed was awarded, because it had not been explained how the invoices were made up (District Court of Rotterdam 2024, paras 2.9-2.10). More on this type of dispute at commercial litigation.

Frequently asked questions

May a company refuse a GDPR access request?

The right of access under Article 15 GDPR is the starting point. For manifestly unfounded or excessive requests, a company may refuse access or charge a reasonable administrative fee (Article 12(5) GDPR). The company must establish that the exception applies. An applicant does not have to give reasons for the request.

When is an access request excessive or an abuse of rights?

A request made to prepare a claim also falls within the right of access (C-307/22). To establish abuse, the controller must clearly demonstrate an improper purpose, such as artificially creating the conditions for compensation. All the circumstances matter. Even a first request may be excessive on that basis (C-526/24).

Can the person making the request claim damages if the online retailer does not answer, or answers late?

They may, if the infringement actually caused damage (Article 82 GDPR). Loss of control over personal data or uncertainty about its processing may qualify. The data subject must actually have suffered that damage, and their own conduct must not have been the determining cause (C-526/24, operative part, points 2 and 3).

Cited case law

Court of Justice of the European Union

Courts of appeal

District courts

Administrative court

See also