Expired terms of office at Dutch foundations
A Dutch foundation may keep operating after its directors' terms have expired, while they remain registered. At a church foundation in Zaandam, the court appointed the people already running it. Section 2:299 of the Dutch Civil Code provides a remedy when the board is incomplete and the articles offer no solution. How does that petition work, and who is appointed?
Church foundation continued for years without reappointments
The treasurer of Stichting Servisch Orthodoxe Kerk in Nederland had been on the Trade Register since 2015, and the chair since 2016. The articles of association provided for two-year terms, but there was no evidence of reappointment. Nevertheless, they appointed a secretary in 2023 and two more directors in April 2026. When a dispute arose with the bishop, the validity of the board's appointments came before the Noord-Holland District Court.
The foundation relied on the provision in its articles stating that directorship ended on resignation, death or removal. That provision, however, was expressly subject to the preceding provisions, which the court held included the two-year term. The treasurer had therefore ceased to be a director in October 2017, and the chair in April 2018. Their later appointments could not fill the vacancies. An implied reappointment was possible, but required specific facts from which a resolution could be inferred. Remaining on the register was insufficient (Noord-Holland District Court 2026, paras 5.9-5.13).
The bishop and secretary sought the appointment of five people, including themselves. On 18 August 2026, the court chose the three people who had been running the foundation. Their experience and the financial improvements achieved outweighed the wish to replace almost the entire board. Having run the foundation for years without valid appointments did not prevent the court from appointing them (Noord-Holland District Court 2026, paras 5.19-5.20 and 5.24).
The statutory remedy is Section 2:299 of the Dutch Civil Code (DCC). Where all or part of the board required by the articles is missing and appointments are not made under the articles, the district court may appoint directors on a petition by an interested party or the Public Prosecution Service. It must follow the articles as far as possible. The assessment can be organised around three questions: is the board incomplete, can the foundation resolve the problem itself, and whom can the court appoint? The broader framework is explained in the overview of Dutch foundation law.
First establish who is still legally a director
The starting point is the number of directors: according to the Supreme Court, Section 2:299 DCC applies where a foundation has no directors or fewer than the minimum required by its articles. If the board is complete but the roles of chair and treasurer have been allocated incorrectly, this provision offers no remedy for that defect (Supreme Court 7 September 2012, para. 3.3).
That count must reflect who remains validly in office. A term that has expired without reappointment can leave an apparently complete board without any directors. The articles are decisive: any provision allowing directors to remain in office after expiry must be considered. Without such a provision, a former director cannot fill the vacancy by appointing successors after leaving office. The Utrecht Subdistrict Court held that such appointment resolutions were void (Utrecht Subdistrict Court 2018, para. 4.3).
Appointment under the articles must offer a real solution
An incomplete board is insufficient on its own, as Structured Investments B illustrates. Trust services provider TMF had been the Amsterdam foundation's sole director. When TMF resigned, no directors remained, but the articles still gave TMF the power to appoint a successor. At the hearing, a member of staff confirmed that TMF was willing to cooperate. The court therefore dismissed the petition: the foundation could still fill the vacancy under its own articles (Amsterdam District Court 2024, Structured Investments B, paras 4.2-4.3).
If only the existing directors may appoint successors and none remains in office, the court can fill the vacancy (Amsterdam District Court 2024, Structured Investments C, para. 4.3). A deadlock within the body making appointments may also justify intervention. The Gelderland District Court appointed the chair of a trust office foundation (stichting administratiekantoor, or STAK) after one of the other two directors had blocked his reappointment following the expiry of his term (Gelderland District Court 2025, paras 4.7 and 4.11-4.13).
Sometimes the articles contain no appointment procedure at all, although Section 2:286(4)(c) DCC requires one. In a Noord-Holland case, this coincided with uncertainty over the validity of earlier appointments. The court treated that combination as equivalent to a board vacancy and appointed the people who had been acting as directors (Noord-Holland District Court 2025, para. 2.6).
The articles and a functioning board guide the choice
Eligibility for appointment depends primarily on the articles. Three former directors of a Rotterdam foundation sought reappointment, but two had passed the age limit of 72 set by the articles. The court therefore appointed the three candidates proposed as an alternative: one former director and two new directors, all below that age limit (Rotterdam District Court 2025, paras 4.5-4.6). Experience and continuity can carry considerable weight, as at the church foundation, but do not entitle a candidate to appointment.
The requirement to follow the articles as far as possible also leaves room for a tailored solution, as the differing decisions on remuneration show. In 2011, The Hague District Court rejected candidates who would act only for a fee prohibited by the articles and with insurance paid for by the foundation. In 2026, the Amsterdam District Court allowed the costs of a director it had identified to be charged to the foundation temporarily, expressly departing from the articles (The Hague District Court 2011, para. 4.10; Amsterdam District Court 2026, paras 4.27-4.28). A request to appoint a candidate who requires payment therefore calls for specific justification.
The number of appointments also needs attention. Sometimes appointing one director is sufficient if that director may then fill the remaining vacancies (The Hague District Court July 2026, para. 3.4). Check whether that director can make decisions and represent the foundation alone. In 2016, the Amsterdam District Court appointed one board member but observed that filling the other seats was the obvious next step, given the requirements of unanimity and joint representation (Amsterdam District Court 2016, para. 3.6).
How does a foundation or STAK appointment petition work?
The same appointment procedure applies to a STAK: the petition must establish the board vacancy and offer a workable solution. Preparation and proceedings involve the following steps:
-
Establish the appointment history using the Trade Register, the articles, appointment resolutions and any reappointments. Record when each director's term ended and who retains the power to appoint a successor. Explain why appointment under the articles offers no solution. An outdated entry in the register alone does not establish the legal position.
-
Explain why the petitioner has standing. An interested party is someone whose own interests may be affected by the outcome, or whose involvement in the subject matter is sufficiently close to justify participation (Supreme Court 12 October 2018, para. 4.1.2). Former directors and depositary receipt holders may qualify. In Amsterdam, the trustee in bankruptcy of the sole depositary receipt holder brought the petition; the Enterprise Chamber also identified the underlying company as a potential petitioner (Amsterdam District Court 2016, para. 3.4; Enterprise Chamber 28 March 2018, para. 3.23).
-
A lawyer must sign the petition (Section 278(3) of the Dutch Code of Civil Procedure, DCCP). It is filed with the district court for the foundation's registered office (Section 995(1) DCCP). Include a current Trade Register extract, the current articles and written confirmations that the candidates are willing to accept appointment. Explain their eligibility and how appointing them will restore a functioning board (The Hague District Court July 2026, paras 3.1 and 3.4).
-
Identify the known interested parties and their addresses, including a STAK's depositary receipt holders. The court may summon them (Section 279(1) DCCP), as happened in the Gelderland STAK case (Gelderland District Court 2025, para. 1.1). The foundation must be summoned in any event (Section 995(3) DCCP). If no objections are raised after an opportunity to respond, the court may decide the petition without a hearing (Noord-Holland District Court 2024, paras 2.5-2.6).
-
Request provisional enforceability if the new directors need to act immediately, so that the appointment can take effect pending an appeal. The court registrar registers the appointment only once the decision is no longer open to appeal (Section 2:302 DCC). That later registration must be distinguished from the legal effect of the appointment itself.
-
Bear the fixed appeal period in mind. An appeal must be lodged within three months of the decision, including by an interested party who was not summoned and did not know about it (Section 996(f) DCCP; Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal 2020, para. 4.4).
A court appointment fills a vacancy on the board. The new board must then ensure that future appointments and reappointments take place on time and are properly recorded.
Frequently asked questions
Does a foundation without directors continue to exist?
Yes. Having no directors does not itself dissolve a foundation. For a foundation without a registered business, dissolution by the Chamber of Commerce requires a year without registered directors, or with only deceased or uncontactable directors, and the foundation itself being uncontactable at its address (Section 2:19a(2) DCC). Notice must first be given, with eight weeks to remedy the position.
Can the court also appoint a supervisory board member?
Section 2:299 DCC concerns directors. A clause in the articles may support appointment of a supervisor without specific statutory authority: a welwillendheidsbeslissing. This requires a need that cannot reasonably be met otherwise. The appointment must serve the legitimate interests involved, or at least not run counter to them (The Hague District Court August 2026, paras 3.2-3.5).
Can the Enterprise Chamber restore a STAK's board?
A STAK without a business falls outside inquiry proceedings: investigations into legal entities' policy and affairs. The underlying company may be investigated and its shares placed under temporary administration (Enterprise Chamber 3 June 2013, paras 3.3 and 3.33). For appointing directors, the Enterprise Chamber refers to Section 2:299 DCC (Enterprise Chamber 28 March 2018, para. 3.23).
Cited case law
Supreme Court
- Supreme Court 7 September 2012, ECLI:NL:HR:2012:BW5355: Section 2:299 DCC applies where there are no directors or fewer than the minimum required by the articles; an incorrect allocation of roles within a complete board falls outside it (para. 3.3).
- Supreme Court 12 October 2018, ECLI:NL:HR:2018:1900, Stichting ANV Fondsen: the interested-party test also applies under Section 2:299 DCC; the severity of the intervention belongs in the substantive assessment (paras 4.1.2 and 4.2).
Enterprise Chamber
- Enterprise Chamber 3 June 2013, ECLI:NL:GHAMS:2013:CA3555: a STAK without its own business falls outside inquiry proceedings; the underlying company may be investigated and its shares placed under temporary administration (paras 3.3 and 3.33).
- Enterprise Chamber 28 March 2018, ECLI:NL:GHAMS:2018:1149: where the STAK's board lacks a succession procedure, any interested party, including the company, may petition the district court for appointments (para. 3.23).
Courts of appeal
- Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal 18 February 2020, ECLI:NL:GHARL:2020:1367: an appeal against appointment of a STAK director must be lodged within three months of the decision, including by a depositary receipt holder who was not summoned (para. 4.4).
District courts
- The Hague District Court 27 January 2011, ECLI:NL:RBSGR:2011:BP4427: candidates requiring a fee prohibited by the articles were not appointed (para. 4.10).
- Utrecht Subdistrict Court 28 March 2018, ECLI:NL:RBMNE:2018:1198: a former director cannot appoint successors after expiry of the term; such appointment resolutions are void (para. 4.3).
- Amsterdam District Court 30 June 2016, ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2016:4016: the trustee in bankruptcy of the sole depositary receipt holder has standing; appointing one director calls for attention to joint decision-making and representation (paras 3.4 and 3.6).
- Amsterdam District Court 2 May 2024, ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2024:2507, Structured Investments B: petition dismissed because the body authorised to appoint under the articles confirmed its willingness to cooperate at the hearing (paras 4.2-4.3).
- Amsterdam District Court 2 May 2024, ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2024:2508, Structured Investments C: where only the board may appoint and there are no directors, only the district court can fill the vacancy (para. 4.3).
- Noord-Holland District Court 28 March 2024, ECLI:NL:RBNHO:2024:3092: a petition may be decided without a hearing after an opportunity to object and in the absence of objections (paras 2.5-2.6).
- Gelderland District Court 27 January 2025, ECLI:NL:RBGEL:2025:3055: depositary receipt holders were summoned; a former STAK chair was reappointed despite objections (paras 1.1 and 4.13).
- Noord-Holland District Court 25 March 2025, ECLI:NL:RBNHO:2025:3217: uncertainty over earlier appointments combined with a complete absence of appointment provisions in the articles was treated as a board vacancy (para. 2.6).
- Rotterdam District Court 26 August 2025, ECLI:NL:RBROT:2025:10285: the age limit in the articles prevented reappointment of two former directors; the court appointed the alternative candidates (paras 4.5-4.6).
- Amsterdam District Court 8 January 2026, ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2026:7177: the court appointed a director it had identified to fill the remaining vacancies and temporarily permitted payment in departure from the articles (paras 4.27-4.28).
- The Hague District Court 31 July 2026, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2026:22398: register extract, articles and confirmations of willingness required; one appointment is sufficient if an incomplete board may fill its own vacancies (paras 3.1 and 3.4).
- The Hague District Court 10 August 2026, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2026:23973: appointment of a supervisory board member without a specific statutory basis requires an otherwise unmet need and compatibility with the legitimate interests involved (paras 3.2-3.5).
- Noord-Holland District Court 18 August 2026, ECLI:NL:RBNHO:2026:9685: a director's term ends automatically on expiry; registration is no substitute for reappointment; the court appointed the people who had been acting as directors (paras 5.9, 5.13 and 5.20).