Skip to content

Removal of a foundation director by the court: when does the court intervene?

17 April 2026Juriaan de Vries

Court-ordered removal and the foundation's interests

A foundation director may be removed for neglect of duty, but also where a board deadlock seriously impairs the foundation's functioning. Decisions from 2026 illustrate both situations. Standing to bring the petition, the grounds for removal and the possible five-year director disqualification each require a separate assessment.

Updated on 4 November 2026.

Section 2:298 DCC provides four grounds for removal

Under Section 2:298(1) of the Dutch Civil Code (DCC), the district court may remove a foundation director for neglect of duty, other weighty reasons or a substantial change in circumstances in which continued service as a director can no longer reasonably be tolerated. A fourth ground is failure to comply, or to comply properly, with a court order under Section 2:297 DCC.

The grounds for removal were expanded on 1 July 2021. Conduct contrary to the law or the articles of association may constitute neglect of duty or another weighty reason. A lasting deadlock in decision-making may also justify intervention. Systematic self-enrichment or financial mismanagement is therefore not a prerequisite for every removal. Where older conduct is involved, the applicable statutory regime requires attention.

A petition by an interested party or the Public Prosecution Service is required. The district court has no general power to initiate or continue removal proceedings of its own motion. During pending proceedings, it may take interim measures. This distinction became decisive when petitioners withdrew their removal petition: the legal basis for the investigation by a temporary director also fell away (The Hague District Court, August 2026, paras 3.8-3.12).

Obstructing recovery of personal debts led to removal from the STAK

On 14 August 2026, the Gelderland District Court removed a director of a foundation administering company shares, known as a STAK. The director owed personal debts to the underlying private limited company (BV) and was also a director and priority shareholder of that company. The court found that he had used his control to prevent the BV from recovering its claims against him. His duties as a STAK director also required him to prevent that obstruction. His conduct within the BV therefore affected the assessment of his duties at the STAK (Gelderland District Court, August 2026, para. 4.6).

The combination of his different roles, the risk of further obstruction and the seriously damaged relationship with his fellow director also justified removal on grounds of other weighty reasons or substantially changed circumstances. No STAK board meetings had taken place for years. The court thus examined the actual effects of the conflicting interests on both legal entities (Gelderland District Court, August 2026, paras 4.8-4.11).

The court drew a financial distinction. Non-payment did not, in itself, reduce the BV's equity: its claims remained in existence. Its liquidity was affected, however. This distinction avoids supporting allegations about a board dispute with a loss of assets that has not been established (Gelderland District Court, August 2026, para. 4.7). The removal concerned his position at the STAK; the order did not also remove him as a director of the BV.

A deadlocked board can be removed without serious blame

A different situation arose at a foundation connected to a property business. Two family factions could not implement the agreed succession arrangements for the board. On 10 April 2026, the Amsterdam Court of Appeal upheld the removal of all incumbent directors. Each could be held responsible for the board's continuing dysfunction. The foundation needed a board capable of taking action (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2026, paras 5.8-5.12).

Removal did not entail director disqualification in that case: the directors' conduct was not sufficiently blameworthy. A collectively caused deadlock can therefore justify removal even where several directors share responsibility (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2026, paras 5.11-5.13).

The same distinction between grounds for removal and blameworthiness appears in an appeal in The Hague. A deadlock prevented the foundation from carrying out its work properly. Convening meetings did not establish that effective decision-making was taking place. The court upheld removal for other weighty reasons, while finding no neglect of duty and imposing no director disqualification (The Hague Court of Appeal 2026, paras 6.4-6.12).

A passive board member also has financial oversight duties

Financial neglect remains a clear ground for removal. In a case concerning care funding, proper records, annual accounts and adequate controls were lacking. The director failed to give a satisfactory explanation for money transfers and the private use of funds. On 19 March 2026, the Amsterdam District Court granted the Public Prosecution Service's removal petition (Amsterdam District Court 2026, paras 3.10-3.17).

The treasurer was also removed. His lack of financial knowledge and limited practical involvement did not excuse him. He should have identified the problems and intervened. The internal allocation of duties may be relevant to individual responsibility, but it does not automatically remove a board member's oversight duties. Both directors were subject to the five-year director disqualification (Amsterdam District Court 2026, paras 3.18-3.19 and operative part 5.1-5.3).

A board dispute requires evidence of its effects

The limits are illustrated by the order of the Rotterdam District Court of 22 October 2026. A founder and former treasurer sought another director's removal. Her objections included expenditure, a possible conflict of interest and relations within the board. The court rejected the petition. The financial allegations were insufficiently substantiated, and the alleged personal benefit had not been established (Rotterdam District Court 2026, paras 5.13-5.16).

Nor had it been shown that necessary or desirable decisions were actually being delayed. The breakdown in relations could not be attributed solely to the respondent either. In these circumstances, there were insufficient grounds for removal. The difference from the Amsterdam deadlock case therefore lay in the evidence of dysfunction and the substantiation of the intervention sought (Rotterdam District Court 2026, paras 5.17-5.19).

The petitioner must be sufficiently involved with the foundation

Standing to bring proceedings is separate from whether removal is justified on the merits. According to the Supreme Court, a person may be an interested party where the outcome sufficiently affects their own interests, or where they are otherwise so closely involved in the subject matter that participation is justified. The far-reaching nature of removal is then assessed on the merits (Supreme Court 12 October 2018, paras 4.1.2-4.2).

A former director may retain sufficient involvement in events from their term of office, provided they file the petition within a reasonable period after leaving. What is reasonable depends on the circumstances (Supreme Court 10 November 2006, paras 3.4.2-3.4.3). In the Rotterdam case, the petitioner retained standing after being removed herself during the proceedings, because she had been involved in the financial matters to which her petition related (Rotterdam District Court 2026, paras 5.7-5.8).

Family ties, emotional involvement or a wish to use the foundation's property are insufficient in themselves. The Gelderland District Court held petitions inadmissible where the petitioners could not establish a sufficient personal interest or close involvement. General concerns about the foundation's interests do not give everyone standing (Gelderland District Court, March 2026, paras 4.3-4.9).

Suspension can provide protection during the investigation

Removal proceedings can take time. Section 2:298(2) DCC allows suspension and other interim measures affecting the board, including the appointment of a temporary director. A justified concern that a ground for removal exists may suffice for interim suspension. The final decision on removal follows later (Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal 2026, paras 3.16-3.24).

The measure must address the particular risk, such as blocked decisions, opaque money transfers or the exclusion of a fellow director. The duration of a temporary appointment, the director's powers and access to information also require attention. Interim suspension does not in itself amount to final removal.

The five-year director disqualification has its own exception

Under Section 2:298(3) DCC, a director removed by the district court cannot become a director or supervisory director of a foundation for five years after removal. The statute provides an exception where no serious blame can be attached to the director, taking into account, among other matters, the duties allocated to others. The statutory wording concerns new appointments as a director or supervisory director of a foundation.

The practical difference is substantial. In the Gelderland STAK case, this statutory consequence applied because the court considered the conduct seriously blameworthy. In the Amsterdam deadlock case, no disqualification applied. A petition or defence should therefore address separately the termination of the current appointment and the blameworthiness relevant to the exception from disqualification (Gelderland District Court, August 2026, para. 4.12; Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2026, para. 5.13).

What does this mean for a removal petition or defence?

A properly prepared removal case connects the director's duties to specific acts, decisions and consequences. Financial allegations require attention to the records, bank transactions and explanations requested. A deadlock case must identify which decisions are being delayed, why that affects the foundation and why continuation of the existing board is untenable. A director defending the petition can explain which decisions have been taken and how the foundation's interests have been served.

Jurisdiction generally lies with the district court for the foundation's registered office. Section 995 of the Dutch Code of Civil Procedure (DCCP) also requires the petition to identify the foundation and its place of domicile and requires the court to order that it be called to the proceedings. This is a requirement to give notice, not an obligation to appear. In the Gelderland STAK case, the court considered separate notice pointless because both directors, each independently authorised to represent the foundation, were already participating and had explained their opposing positions. That conclusion depends on the particular procedural circumstances (Gelderland District Court, August 2026, paras 4.1-4.2).

Finally, the composition of the board after removal requires attention. Where there is a genuine vacancy, Section 2:299 DCC may provide a basis for the appointment of new foundation directors. A coordinated petition should explain who can manage the foundation on an interim or permanent basis and which powers are needed.

Frequently asked questions

Can a director avoid removal by resigning?

A director who has validly resigned cannot be removed from the same position again. Decisions may still be needed on matters such as costs or a successor. In a Hague STAK case, the petition to remove directors who had resigned was rejected, but they were nevertheless ordered to pay the costs of the proceedings (The Hague District Court, July 2026, paras 4.9-4.10 and 4.20).

Can the court also remove a foundation's supervisory director?

Yes. Section 2:298(4) DCC applies the removal provisions to supervisory directors by analogy. The supervisory director's performance of their particular duties and the alleged ground for removal must likewise be substantiated. Interim measures and the statutory consequences of court-ordered removal also require separate consideration.

What happens if the removal petition is withdrawn?

Withdrawal before a final order has been made can also remove the legal basis for interim board measures. This affects a temporary director and their investigation. In a Hague case, the court ended the proceedings and all interim measures following withdrawal, despite the temporary director's concerns about the foundation (The Hague District Court, August 2026, paras 3.8-3.13).

Cited case law

See also