Skip to content

Sea Shepherd: removal of foundation directors void

6 April 2026Juriaan de Vries

Removing foundation directors and unanimity under the articles

On 9 December 2025, the Amsterdam Court of Appeal declared two resolutions removing directors of Sea Shepherd Global void. The articles required every other director to vote in favour. Four votes on a six-member board were insufficient. Yet the directors obtained no access to the records: a court had subsequently removed them, and they established no special circumstances justifying access.

Four members of a six-member board resolve to remove colleagues

The dispute arose after the founder of the Sea Shepherd movement broke with its American organisation, Sea Shepherd Conservation Society, in 2022. Four fellow directors of Stichting Sea Shepherd Global resolved to remove him with immediate effect over Zoom on 9 August 2022. Neither the founder nor a second director had been invited to that meeting. (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2025, paras 3.6-3.7)

Five months later, on 23 January 2023, the same four board members removed the second director. This time she had been invited, but did not attend after her request for the reasons for removal went unanswered. The founder received no invitation, despite arguing that his earlier removal was invalid and he remained entitled to vote. (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2025, paras 3.13-3.16)

The district court had annulled both resolutions for breaches of the rules governing how resolutions are adopted. On appeal, the directors sought a declaration that the resolutions had been void from the outset. The court of appeal agreed on that point. (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2025, paras 4.2, 6.2-6.6)

The court reads "the other directors jointly" as requiring unanimity

Article 9(4) of the articles of association provided that, where more than two directors held office, a director could be removed by "the other directors jointly". The court interpreted this provision objectively, considering its wording and the articles as a whole. Every director except the one facing removal had to vote in favour. Otherwise, the provision would add nothing to the ordinary majority rule. The use of the word "unanimously" elsewhere did not alter that interpretation. (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2025, paras 6.4-6.5)

Removing the founder therefore also required the second director's approval. Without it, he remained in office. His approval was consequently required to remove that second director in turn. The second resolution also lacked the necessary majority. (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2025, para. 6.6)

That defect makes a resolution void under Section 2:14(1) of the Dutch Civil Code (DCC). The Supreme Court had already held that the absence of a majority required by law or the articles makes a resolution void. This differs from a breach of rules governing how resolutions are adopted, such as a defect in convening a meeting, which may make a resolution voidable under Section 2:15(1)(a) DCC. (Supreme Court 10 July 2020, para. 3.2.2)

Subsequent removal by the court limits access to records

Because the resolutions were void, the two had remained directors for longer than the commercial register showed. Their terms nevertheless ended on 20 December 2023, when the district court removed them in separate proceedings under Section 2:298(1) DCC. That removal was upheld on appeal. Their claim to information was therefore assessed on the basis that they were former directors. (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2025, paras 6.8-6.10)

A former director is in principle no longer entitled to access the legal entity's records. The court of appeal recognised that special circumstances may justify an exception, for example to account for past conduct or answer allegations about the director's performance. The former director must explain specifically why particular documents are needed. (Supreme Court 24 November 2017, para. 4.2); (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2025, para. 6.11)

The two referred only in general terms to their former responsibilities. They did not explain which documents they needed to account for their conduct or defend themselves. The founder's wish to reach SSG's support base did not justify access either. His own organisation, CPWF, was already active by then. The court dismissed the claim. (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2025, paras 3.9-3.10, 6.11)

The other board resolutions remain effective

The void removals did not automatically invalidate later resolutions. The annual accounts for 2022 had been adopted in March 2024, after the court had removed the two directors. Their involvement was no longer required at that point. (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2025, paras 6.19-6.20)

No special majority requirement had been asserted for entering into the cooperation with the American organisation. The court proceeded on the basis that any board resolution required could be adopted by an ordinary majority. The four other directors could provide that majority. The failure to invite the two amounted at most to a defect in how the resolution was adopted. Any claim for annulment was also defeated by the period in Section 2:15(5) DCC having expired. Each resolution therefore required its own assessment. (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2025, para. 6.21)

What should a foundation board check before removing a director?

A foundation's articles of association determine who has power to remove a director and which votes are required. At SSG, the other colleague's approval was needed in addition to the votes of the four directors proposing removal. A proper invitation alone would not have cured that shortfall: the necessary votes in favour had to be cast.

For each resolution, record who holds office at that point, which majority is required and how the votes were cast. The Sea Shepherd outcome also shows why removal by fellow directors and removal by the court require separate assessment. The failure of the first route did not prevent subsequent removal by the court.

Frequently asked questions

Does the director facing removal have to vote on their own removal?

In this case, unanimity concerned all the other directors. The vote of the director facing removal was not required for that purpose. With six directors, five votes in favour were therefore needed. That result rests on the interpretation of SSG's articles; the provisions of another foundation's own articles must be examined separately.

What period applies to challenging a voidable resolution?

Under Section 2:15(5) DCC, the power to seek annulment lapses one year after the end of the day on which sufficient publicity was given to the resolution or the interested party learnt of it or was notified. This specific forfeiture period concerns annulment. It provides no general reason to delay asserting that a resolution is void.

Does this judgment rule out every request for documents by a former director?

The court assessed access arising from former directorship. Counsel confirmed that no inspection request under Section 843a of the Dutch Code of Civil Procedure (as formerly in force) was before it. Obtaining particular documents on a separate statutory basis requires an assessment against the conditions of that basis. (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2025, para. 6.9)

Cited case law

See also