Dismissing a director: the right to advise
A statutory director must have a meaningful opportunity to advise on proposed dismissal. Overijssel District Court found a company seriously culpable for presenting the director’s departure as a fait accompli. Yet the CEO received only €10,000 fair compensation: the grounds were sufficient, and he would have been dismissed even after a proper decision-making process.
Departure was settled before the meeting
The CEO worked for a Dutch subsidiary of a Norwegian seafood producer. Before the general meeting, the company announced his departure internally, blocked his telephone number and removed his registration as a director at the Chamber of Commerce. A final payment and settlement agreement had also been discussed. These successive steps were central to the decision of 13 July 2026 (paras 5.9-5.11).
The director's dual legal relationship
A statutory director (bestuurder) who is also an employee has a dual legal relationship with the company: as a director under company law, and as an employee under employment law. Dismissal as a director is governed by Section 2:244 DCC; dismissal as an employee by employment law. Since the Supreme Court's judgments of 15 April 2005, a valid dismissal decision by the general meeting in principle also terminates the employment contract, unless a statutory prohibition on notice or a contrary agreement stands in the way (Supreme Court 15 April 2005, Unidek). Disputes over that employment relationship go not to the subdistrict court but to the commercial court, even after the appointment as director has ended (Section 2:241 DCC; Supreme Court 17 November 1995).
Advice requires an open decision-making process
In the general meeting the director has an advisory vote (Section 2:227(7) DCC), including where that meeting concerns his own dismissal. That right is not intended as a formality: the advice must still be capable of being meaningful. That means the director must be given the opportunity to give reasoned advice and that this advice can genuinely contribute to the decision-making. Where the advice is given merely for form's sake because the outcome is already fixed, the right to advise is breached and the decision is voidable for a defect in its formation (Section 2:15(1)(a) DCC).
The court considered that these steps showed the dismissal was already settled. The director’s advice could therefore no longer influence the decision. The resolution was voidable for infringement of Section 2:227(7) DCC. In these circumstances, the company’s conduct was also seriously culpable (Overijssel District Court 2026, paras 5.9-5.11).
The error is not unique. In a Limburg case a dismissal decision failed on the same ground; because there the director claimed annulment of the decision, the decision fell away and the employment relationship continued (Limburg District Court 2019). That explains why it went differently here: the CEO withdrew his request for annulment (Overijssel District Court 2026, para. 5.6) and sought only fair compensation, so that the decision, though voidable, remained in force. It can also go well: where the meeting is convened in good time, the agenda names the dismissal, and the director can actually cast his advisory vote, the decision stands (North Holland District Court 2026).
A reasonable ground for dismissal after all
A defectively taken decision does not mean the dismissal is groundless. For a statutory director too, the company needs a reasonable ground to give notice of the employment contract (Section 7:669 DCC). The company relied on the "h ground" (Section 7:669(3)(h) DCC): an irreparable breakdown of trust. The statements of the fellow board members and the parent company showed that the CEO had repeatedly had concerns about his performance raised with him, among other things around a product recall and a warning from the food-safety authority, without this leading to any change.
The court finds that breakdown of trust sufficiently established (Overijssel District Court 2026, para. 5.23). Redeployment was not appropriate at board level (Overijssel District Court 2026, para. 5.24). The notice itself therefore stands; a claim for fair compensation in connection with termination must be distinguished from annulment of the corporate dismissal resolution. Reinstatement through the ordinary employment-law route is excluded for this director.
Why fair compensation was limited to €10,000
The court awarded fair compensation for the seriously culpable conduct. Its amount is assessed by reference to the factors from New Hairstyle and ServiceNow (Supreme Court 30 June 2017; Supreme Court 30 November 2018): among others the degree of culpability, the "value of the employment contract" and the consequences of the dismissal. Decisive is that the ground for dismissal was fully made out. The court considers it implausible that the director's advice would have led to a different outcome, so that he would have been dismissed even without the defect (Overijssel District Court 2026, para. 5.27). There is, moreover, no serious loss of income, given his age and experience. That is why the court arrives, despite the seriously culpable conduct, at fair compensation of €10,000 (Overijssel District Court 2026, para. 5.29).
The bonus condition remained decisive
The bonus claim also failed. The court holds that its award was not entirely discretionary, so that the director could in principle claim it (Overijssel District Court 2026, para. 5.33). But the scheme required, for payment, a "non-terminated position" at the moment of payment in April, and at that moment the director had been dismissed. A reliance on reasonableness and fairness failed, because he had not sought annulment of the dismissal decision (Overijssel District Court 2026, paras 5.34-5.35).
What does this mean for the company and the director?
The company must keep the decision open until the director has had an opportunity to advise. This requires a clear agenda and a genuine opportunity to exercise the advisory vote. Which preparatory measures remain appropriate depends on the circumstances. Sufficient grounds for dismissal do not cure an earlier infringement of the right to advise.
The director must distinguish annulment of the corporate dismissal from fair compensation for the way dismissal was handled. Here, the resolution stood after the annulment request was withdrawn, which also affected the bonus claim. The compensation assessment additionally considered how employment would have continued without the defect.
Frequently asked questions
Does a statutory director have a right to advise on their own dismissal?
Yes. A director has an advisory vote in the general meeting under Section 2:227(7) DCC, including on their own dismissal. They must be able to support their advice with reasons, and the decision must remain open. An infringement may make the resolution voidable; annulment must be sought in time.
Does infringement of the right to advise lead to high compensation?
That depends on all the circumstances. Here, the conduct was seriously culpable, but the director would have been dismissed without the procedural defect too. The court also expected him to find new work quickly. It therefore awarded €10,000 fair compensation; that sum is not a general benchmark for infringements of advisory rights.
Does the employment contract end automatically with dismissal as director?
Where the director is also an employee, valid dismissal as director generally also ends employment. The Supreme Court established this rule on 15 April 2005. A statutory prohibition on notice or an agreement to the contrary may provide an exception. Both the company-law and employment-law assessments therefore remain relevant.
Cited case law
Supreme Court
- Supreme Court 30 November 2018, ECLI:NL:HR:2018:2218: fair compensation takes account of how long employment would probably have continued without the seriously culpable conduct (paras 3.4.2-3.4.3).
- Supreme Court 30 June 2017, ECLI:NL:HR:2017:1187: fair compensation requires assessment of all relevant circumstances, including lost income and other employment (paras 3.4.5-3.4.6).
- Supreme Court 15 April 2005, ECLI:NL:HR:2005:AS2030: dismissal as director generally also ends employment; a statutory prohibition on notice or a contrary agreement may prevent that (paras 3.4.2-3.4.3).
- Supreme Court 17 November 1995, ECLI:NL:HR:1995:ZC1887: cited on the commercial court’s jurisdiction over employment disputes with a former director (Overijssel District Court 13 July 2026, para. 5.2 and footnote).
District courts
- Overijssel District Court 13 July 2026, ECLI:NL:RBOVE:2026:4528: presenting dismissal as a fait accompli infringed the advisory right; the circumstances warranted €10,000 fair compensation (paras 5.9-5.11 and 5.27-5.29).
- North Holland District Court 11 February 2026, ECLI:NL:RBNHO:2026:1375: the director could advise in advance and had been adequately heard; the dismissal resolution stood (paras 4.5 and 4.10).
- Limburg District Court 9 January 2019, ECLI:NL:RBLIM:2019:125: following annulment for infringement of the advisory right, employment also continued in this case (paras 4.17-4.22 and 6.1).
See also
- Shareholder disputes: disputes within the company and the route to court
- Buying out a fellow shareholder: three routes out of a conflict between shareholders