STAK decertification and dissolution during a dispute
The Amsterdam Court of Appeal temporarily barred certain depositary receipt holders from resolving to decertify and dissolve a trust office foundation (STAK). Their authority was disputed and the Enterprise Chamber had already placed the shares under administration. Preserving the existing position prevailed in those circumstances. Section 2:8 DCC informed the balance, rather than imposing a general bar during litigation.
Court temporarily bars decertification and dissolution resolutions
A trust office foundation (stichting administratiekantoor, STAK) held all shares in a company and had issued 3,200 depositary receipts. One legal entity held 1,600; a family held the other half. The STAK’s three directors were seriously divided, as were its receipt holders (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2025, paras 2.1-2.3).
In May 2025 the Amsterdam District Court had dismissed all three directors and appointed a successor. That decision was under appeal. In separate inquiry proceedings concerning the company, the Enterprise Chamber had transferred all shares temporarily to an independent administrator. Earlier agreed principles for changes to the STAK board had not been implemented (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2025, paras 2.3.1-2.4).
A meeting on decertification and dissolution failed to reach the quorum requiring all receipt holders to be present or represented. Another meeting had been called for 30 October 2025. One group argued that this meeting could decide without a quorum by a two-thirds majority of votes cast. Both the applicable version of the articles and that interpretation were disputed (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2025, paras 2.5-2.8).
The group seeking those resolutions held more than two-thirds of the receipts. It sought direct control of the company through decertification. The other two directors, together with the STAK, sought provisional relief under Section 223 DCCP prohibiting those resolutions and suspending their fellow director.
Balance of interests favours temporarily preserving the existing position
The court barred the relevant receipt holders from resolving to decertify and dissolve for the duration of the appeal. It did not finally determine their authority to do so. It identified a real prospect of far-reaching effects on governance, the disputed articles and other proceedings, probably generating further litigation (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2025, para. 3.3 and the operative part, para. 4.1).
Decertification would meanwhile not provide the intended immediate control: the shares were expected to remain under administration. This combination favoured preserving the existing position over immediate resolutions based on a disputed interpretation of the articles. The expected limited duration of the prohibition also mattered. This was a specific balancing exercise under Section 2:8 DCC (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2025, para. 3.3).
The procedural route also remained available. In this case, the possibility of provisional measures concerning the board under Section 2:298 DCC did not exclude relief under Section 223 DCCP. The relief sought was sufficiently connected to the main proceedings (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2025, paras 3.1 and 3.3).
The court refused suspension. Provisionally, all three directors had to be treated as remaining in office: the appeal suspended the dismissal decision, which had not been declared enforceable pending appeal. Here too, preserving the existing position outweighed the interest in intervention (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2025, paras 3.4-3.5).
What does this mean for receipt holders in a dispute?
A majority under the articles answers only part of whether major resolutions during a conflict are appropriate. Here, the disputed articles, existing share administration, effects on litigation and limited immediate benefit of decertification also mattered. The court ruled provisionally on that combination, rather than finally on the STAK’s dissolution.
If a STAK no longer has the directors its articles require and appointments are not made under those articles, court appointment of directors under Section 2:299 DCC may offer a solution.
The decision does not require receipt holders in every dispute to await the outcome of all proceedings. A party relying on a proposed resolution must explain its authority and the interest in deciding at that time. Existing court measures and their consequences also matter. Related topics appear under corporate litigation and shareholder disputes.
Frequently asked questions
What is decertification of shares in a STAK?
Decertification cancels depositary receipts and transfers the underlying shares directly to their holders. It can end the separation between economic interest and control. The articles and administration conditions determine the precise possibilities. Court-ordered share administration can remain in place, so acquiring shares does not necessarily allow immediate free exercise of voting rights.
Can a majority of depositary receipt holders always resolve to dissolve?
The articles must grant that authority and the requirements for a valid resolution must be met. Section 2:8 DCC also limits the exercise of powers. Here, the articles were disputed and the particular balance of interests justified a temporary prohibition. The court therefore did not finally establish that the majority could dissolve the STAK.
What role does the Enterprise Chamber play in a STAK dispute?
In inquiry proceedings concerning the underlying company, the Enterprise Chamber can impose immediate measures such as temporary share administration. This can affect what receipt holders achieve through decertification. In this case, administration prevented the intended immediate control, while the ordinary Court of Appeal assessed the temporary prohibition on resolutions.
Cited case law
- Amsterdam Court of Appeal 29 October 2025, ECLI:NL:GHAMS:2025:3793: a temporary prohibition followed from the specific balance of interests; Section 223 DCCP remained available alongside Section 2:298 DCC (paras 3.1 and 3.3-3.6).