Skip to content

Acquisition warranties: when is a forecast misleading?

13 July 2026Juriaan de Vries

Warranties and forecasts in a business acquisition

A disappointing profit forecast does not automatically make a seller liable. In an acquisition dispute, the Amsterdam Court of Appeal distinguished the accuracy of existing figures, the basis for expectations and contractual restrictions on relying on mistake or rescission. The buyer had negotiated a discount, but that did not settle potential errors in the information supplied. The financial consequences also required separate assessment.

A forecast of €3.7 million, a result of €427,000

In July 2018, a company acquired all the shares in Fresh Leaf, the holding company of machinery manufacturer FTNON. The sellers expected EBITDA for 2018, a measure of operating performance, of approximately €3.7 million. The buyer considered that expectation too optimistic. Following negotiations, the enterprise value was reduced by €2.65 million to €31.75 million. This was the valuation basis for the share price, rather than the share price itself. (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2023, paras 3.7-3.10)

EBITDA for 2018 ultimately amounted to €427,000. That difference did not itself establish a breach of warranty. The buyer had to identify which information supplied at the time of purchase had been inaccurate or misleading. The interim judgment of 18 April 2023 did not award any sum: the court considered expert evidence necessary and invited submissions on the expert and the questions to be addressed. (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2023, paras 4.11 and 4.48-4.50)

The information warranty covers figures and the basis for expectations

The share purchase agreement (SPA) warranted that information supplied was "true, accurate and not misleading". The EBITDA already achieved up to and including May could be assessed for accuracy. For results still to be achieved, the question was whether the forecast was misleading. It could be misleading if facts known at the time had not been adequately reflected and it was reasonably plausible that they were material to the purchase decision. (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2023, para. 4.11)

The warranty was not a promise that the forecast profit would actually be achieved. Nor did a breach of this information warranty require intent: the words "not misleading" concerned the information, rather than the intention with which it had been supplied. The court wanted expert evidence on whether project profits had been recognised prematurely and costs already incurred or foreseeable follow-on costs had not been adequately reflected. (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2023, paras 4.11.1 and 4.34)

Mistake and rescission faced an additional contractual threshold

Section 6:228(2) of the Dutch Civil Code (DCC) precludes reliance on mistake concerning exclusively future circumstances. An incorrect understanding of facts already existing at the time of purchase may, however, provide grounds for mistake. The SPA also restricted the right to annul or vary the agreement for mistake, or to rescind it wholly or in part. Under clause 23.6 of the SPA, this required fraud, gross negligence or intentional conduct. (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2023, paras 4.12 and 4.38)

That conduct did not have to be that of the sellers personally. The exception also covered the specified companies, directors, employees and officers. The buyer had to establish this additional threshold for the allegations on which it based mistake or rescission. An error on one issue did not make those remedies available for every other allegation. Whether a warranty had been breached and which remedy was available therefore required different tests. (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2023, paras 4.38-4.41)

The discount covered the forecast difference the parties had discussed

The sellers pointed to the buyer's professional experience, its advisers and the extensive due diligence. The court did not regard those matters as defeating the potential claim based on mistake. In its view, the buyer had been given no specific reason to doubt the interim results presented or to anticipate follow-on costs of the alleged scale. The information warranty supported its reliance on those figures. (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2023, paras 4.42-4.43)

The discount also had a limited purpose. The parties had used it to bridge their disagreement over projects yet to be secured and future margins. The court did not treat it as settling potential inaccuracies in existing figures or foreseeable project costs. What mattered was the risk for which the discount had been given. This establishes no general rule that investigation or a discount can never affect a subsequent claim. (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2023, para. 4.44)

A breach of warranty does not itself establish a monetary claim

The sellers had incorrectly stated that there was a signed order for the TH Cuisine project. This breached the information warranty. Yet the court rejected the monetary claim based on that breach. The project would not have generated a positive result, and the buyer had also failed to explain adequately why uncertainty about the order would have led to a lower purchase price. The error, the causal connection and the financial consequence each required substantiation. (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2023, paras 4.26-4.29)

The legal basis chosen also determines the calculation. When considering variation for mistake under Section 6:230(2) DCC, the court looked to the price the parties would probably have agreed without the mistake. The buyer's internal calculation was not decisive. Damages for breach of warranty involve a different comparison: in a separate acquisition case, the court compared the buyer's actual position with the position it would have been in had the warranted facts been correct. (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2023, paras 4.45-4.47; Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2020, paras 2.10-2.12)

What does this mean for allocating risk in an acquisition?

Read the warranty alongside the information provisions, limitations of liability and exclusions of remedies. Record which figures are warranted as existing facts, which assumptions underpin a forecast and which specific risk a discount reflects. Anyone identifying an inaccurate figure must then identify both the applicable contractual provision and its consequence for the price or the loss.

A broad opportunity to investigate does not automatically displace specific information provisions. In an "as is, where is" property sale, the seller had to share available reports recording that the sprinkler system had failed inspection. That ruling rested partly on the information provision in the letter of intent and what the buyer was entitled to expect. It therefore gives no general permission to dispense with investigation. (Amsterdam District Court 2024, paras 4.6-4.15)

Conversely, an information error does not suffice for every remedy. In a commercial property sale, a lease addendum had not been supplied, but the seller could not sufficiently appreciate the decisive importance of that tenancy position to the buyer. The breach also did not justify the whole or partial rescission sought. The buyer therefore failed on those grounds. That case underlines why the established error and the remedy chosen each need their own substantiation. (Central Netherlands District Court 2025, paras 3.16-3.22)

Frequently asked questions

What does EBITDA mean in a business acquisition?

EBITDA means earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation. In an acquisition, it may provide a basis for valuation. Check which period it covers and which adjustments have been made. An interim result already achieved and a forecast for the remainder of the year have different implications for the legal assessment.

Is an earn-out a guarantee of future profits?

Under an earn-out, part of the purchase price depends on results achieved later. The parties thus allocate price risk according to agreed conditions. This differs from a fixed price with warranties about information supplied. In the Fresh Leaf case, the parties discussed an earn-out but ultimately chose a fixed discount. (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2023, paras 3.7-3.9)

Does every inaccurate statement entitle the buyer to rescind?

Section 6:265 DCC requires a breach that justifies the rescission sought and its consequences. Where performance is neither permanently nor temporarily impossible, the debtor must also be in default. An acquisition agreement may impose additional restrictions. The word "warranty" does not, by itself, answer those questions.

Cited case law

  • Amsterdam Court of Appeal: 18 April 2023, ECLI:NL:GHAMS:2023:925. Information warranty for an EBITDA forecast, contractual restrictions on remedies and the significance of due diligence and a discount; interim judgment, paras 4.11-4.12 and 4.38-4.47.
  • Amsterdam Court of Appeal: 18 August 2020, ECLI:NL:GHAMS:2020:2299. Assessment of loss by comparison with the position in which the warranted facts were correct, paras 2.10-2.12.
  • Amsterdam District Court: 17 January 2024, ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2024:292. Specific information provisions alongside an "as is" property sale; interim judgment, paras 4.6-4.20.
  • Central Netherlands District Court: 22 January 2025, ECLI:NL:RBMNE:2025:111. Undisclosed lease addendum: what the seller could appreciate for the purposes of mistake, and the seriousness of the breach for rescission, paras 3.16-3.22.

See also