Skip to content

Pre-contractual duty to inform for service providers: what must a lawyer disclose before the engagement?

5 April 2026Juriaan de Vries

Information before the engagement: more than an hourly rate

A lawyer must give a consumer client sufficient information about the services and the resulting obligations before the engagement. Agreeing a price alone is not enough. The scope of the work, contact details, performance and sometimes the right of withdrawal also matter. The applicable rules depend in part on how the contract is concluded.

Four information failures cost a lawyer 40% of his bill

A judgment of the Amsterdam Court of Appeal of 8 July 2025 illustrates this. A lawyer had represented a client in an appeal and in preliminary relief proceedings. The bill came to €8,869.52, of which €1,250 had been paid. The subdistrict court dismissed the payment claim because the lawyer had not adequately explained how the contract was concluded or how he had complied with his information duties.

On appeal, the lawyer recovered part of the claim. The court identified four sufficiently serious failures: inadequate price information, no information about withdrawal, no advance description of the work for the preliminary relief proceedings, and no confirmation meeting the statutory requirements. It reduced the price by 40%, or €3,547.81. After deducting the earlier payment, €4,071.71 remained due. The court did not find the fee clause itself unfair. Compliance with the information duties was a separate question (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2025, paras 5.12-5.17).

Which rules apply to the engagement?

Members of the professions, including lawyers and architects, can be traders for consumer law purposes. A client is a consumer when acting as an individual outside their trade or profession. The first question is whether the contract falls within Division 6.5.2B of the Dutch Civil Code (DCC), which contains statutory exclusions. Three situations must then be distinguished:

  • An ordinary office engagement: Section 6:230l DCC requires clear and intelligible information, unless it is already apparent from the context. This provision also covers other contracts that are neither distance nor off-premises contracts.
  • A distance contract: the stricter rules in Sections 6:230m and 6:230v DCC apply to an organised system for providing services at a distance, using only means of distance communication up to and including conclusion of the contract. A telephone call or email alone does not make an engagement a distance contract.
  • An off-premises contract: more extensive information duties also apply, with the particular requirements for providing information and confirmation in Section 6:230t DCC. A meeting at the client's home is not necessarily the moment when the contract is concluded.

The Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal showed on 25 August 2026 why this distinction matters. A renovation contract concluded by telephone fell within Section 6:230l DCC. The consumer had no right of withdrawal under the distance contract rules. However, the contractor had omitted VAT from the information provided, resulting in a 25% price reduction. That reduction also applied to invoices already paid under the same contract (Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal 2026, paras 4.15 and 4.22-4.24).

Alongside the consumer rules, Sections 6:230b-6:230e DCC impose separate information duties for services within the scope of the Services Directive. They also protect business clients. Basic information must be provided or made accessible in good time. Certain further information, such as a price not fixed in advance, its calculation method or an estimate, and where to find the professional rules, must be supplied on request. The consumer rules may go further and continue to apply alongside these provisions.

What must the client be able to assess in advance?

For a distance contract, Section 6:230m DCC requires the following information, among other things, whenever the particular duty applies. Ordinary office engagements are subject to a shorter list. A single template will therefore not cover every service and every way of concluding a contract.

  • The scope of the service. What matter will be handled, for what purpose and with what foreseeable work? A general description such as ‘legal assistance’ may say too little. A new engagement or substantial extension should make clear what is being added, for example where separate preliminary relief proceedings are commissioned alongside an existing case.
  • Identity and contact details. The provider's identity and the required address and contact details must be clear. This duty concerns more than the name appearing on an invoice later.
  • Price and additional costs. State the total price including taxes or, where it cannot reasonably be calculated in advance, the calculation method and the required information about additional costs. The further requirements for hourly rates are discussed in the article on fee clauses.
  • Payment and performance. This includes the payment method, how and when the service will be performed, the delivery period and, where applicable, the complaints handling policy.
  • Duration and termination. Where applicable, explain the duration, termination conditions and minimum duration of the consumer's obligations. These are different matters: saying that the contract is ‘open-ended’ does not answer every question about termination.
  • Codes of conduct and dispute resolution. Where applicable, provide information about relevant codes of conduct and access to out-of-court complaints or dispute resolution procedures to which the provider subscribes.

The main characteristics of a service and its financial consequences are separate subjects of information. A later dispute about hours wrongly billed does not necessarily mean that the agreed service was unclear beforehand. On 5 December 2025, the Supreme Court upheld a finding in a particular case that the services and the method of calculating the price were sufficiently clear. The accompanying opinion explains this distinction further (Supreme Court 5 December 2025, paras 3.4-3.7; Advocate General 4 July 2025, points 2.31 and 2.37-2.40).

Lawyers: complaints procedures and professional rules

Lawyers are also subject to professional rules. The Dutch Regulation on the Legal Profession generally requires a firm to have a complaints procedure and make it applicable to the engagement. A complaint to the local bar dean or disciplinary proceedings is a different process from resolving a contractual dispute about services or fees. Not every firm must join the Disputes Committee for the Legal Profession. The information should therefore identify the procedure that actually applies and explain how to use it.

A standard term requiring arbitration or binding advice must comply with consumer law. Section 6:236(n) DCC requires, among other things, that the consumer be given at least one month to choose the competent court after the trader invokes the clause in writing.

The professional rules also require more than the price and terms to be recorded. Rule of Conduct 16(1) of the Rules of Conduct for the Legal Profession requires the lawyer to inform the client of important information, facts and agreements and to confirm them in writing, to prevent misunderstanding, uncertainty or dispute. A lawyer who fails to do so bears the evidential risk, according to the Arnhem-Leeuwarden Disciplinary Tribunal on 28 April 2026. A lawyer acting for a mother in proceedings concerning a supervision order for her children had sent no engagement letter and had put nothing in writing about the procedure, strategy, expectations, prospects and risks, although that was certainly required given her personal circumstances and the nature of the case. The tribunal therefore assumed that he had not informed her, or had not informed her sufficiently, on those points (Arnhem-Leeuwarden Disciplinary Tribunal 2026, paras 5.2 and 5.5).

The reprimand the tribunal imposed concerned the conduct as a whole. Later lack of clarity, about the lawyer's attendance at a hearing and about an appeal, also counted, as did earlier disciplinary findings against him (Arnhem-Leeuwarden Disciplinary Tribunal 2026, paras 5.6-5.9 and section 6). The Disciplinary Appeals Tribunal likewise treats the duty as continuing during the engagement: if later developments change the assessment, the lawyer discusses this with the client, who must be aware of the risks attached to his choices (Disciplinary Appeals Tribunal 2026, paras 8.3 and 8.8).

Withdrawal: starting promptly is not a general exception

For distance and off-premises service contracts, consumers generally have fourteen days from conclusion to withdraw (Section 6:230o DCC). Before conclusion, they must receive information about the conditions, time limit and procedure, together with the model withdrawal form. If that information is missing, the period ends no later than twelve months after the original period expired. If the information is supplied within that extended period, the consumer generally has another fourteen days from receipt.

For paid services, the right may be lost once the contract has been fully performed, provided performance began with the consumer's express prior consent and the consumer acknowledged losing the right upon full performance (Section 6:230p(d) DCC). Consent to an early start alone is therefore insufficient. Separate conditions also apply to performance during the withdrawal period and any payment following withdrawal.

This also matters for urgent services. On 30 June 2026, The Hague Court of Appeal held that a funeral services contract was not exempt from withdrawal as a whole merely because the funeral had to take place promptly. The required declarations had not been established. A 25% price reduction for missing withdrawal information remained in place (The Hague Court of Appeal 2026, paras 5.5-5.11). The further consequences are discussed in the article on the right of withdrawal for online services.

Since 25 June 2026, Section 6:230oa DCC also applies to distance contracts concluded through an online interface, such as a website or app. It requires an easily accessible online withdrawal function and the corresponding information. Having a website or accepting an engagement by a standalone email does not in itself bring the contract within these rules. This new duty does not govern the older contracts in the examples discussed above.

Confirmation on a durable medium

For a distance contract, the provider must confirm the contract with the required information on a durable medium within a reasonable time and, at the latest, before performance of the service begins. Information already supplied on such a medium before conclusion need not be supplied again (Section 6:230v(7) DCC). For off-premises contracts, Section 6:230t DCC has its own requirements for providing information and a copy or confirmation of the contract.

An email or PDF can be a durable medium: information addressed personally to the consumer must be capable of being retained and consulted later in an unchanged form, without unilateral alteration by the provider. An ordinary, changeable webpage or a link to such information is insufficient. A protected online account may qualify if the conditions are met, including an active notification that new information is available. The Supreme Court adopted that test in its judgment of 12 November 2021 (Supreme Court 12 November 2021, para. 3.4).

What are the consequences of missing information?

Not every missing statement automatically produces the same reduction. In its judgment of 12 November 2021, the Supreme Court distinguished, for distance and off-premises contracts, duties carrying a specific statutory sanction, essential information duties and other duties. The court examines the first two categories of its own motion, including in default proceedings. There is no general requirement to do so for the remaining duties. Partial annulment requires a sufficiently serious failure; an omission on a minor point may be insufficient (Supreme Court 12 November 2021, paras 3.1.8-3.1.16).

The national sanctions guideline provides guidance but is not binding. The sanction must be effective, proportionate and dissuasive, so the court may depart from it. Actual judgments illustrate the outcomes:

  • A 40% price reduction for the four failures in the Amsterdam lawyer's case in 2025.
  • A 25% reduction for missing withdrawal information in The Hague funeral services case in 2026.
  • A 20% reduction for legal advice in Amsterdam on 28 May 2026. The maximum price was transparent, but withdrawal information was missing. The client had withdrawn too late; a sanction for the information failure remained possible (Amsterdam District Court 2026, paras 4.4-4.6 and 4.11).

Confirmation after conclusion also needs separate attention. In a 2023 webshop case, the advance information was adequate, but the confirmation lacked contact details and withdrawal information. This resulted in a 25% reduction. Another North Holland case, concerning energy supply, involved a combination of missing contact details, minimum duration and the prescribed method of supplying information. It also produced a 25% reduction. These outcomes are not a general tariff for each omitted detail.

Information duties and unfair terms require separate assessments

The substance of contractual terms can also be reviewed. Terms that were not individually negotiated may be assessed for unfairness. Where a fee clause defines the main subject matter of the contract, that assessment becomes available if the term is not plain and intelligible (Section 6:231 DCC). A lack of transparency does not automatically make the term unfair.

This second approach led to fee claims being dismissed in The Hague in 2024 and Central Netherlands in 2024. In Amsterdam in 2026, the court also assessed the initial engagement and a further engagement for preliminary relief proceedings separately. By contrast, The Hague Court of Appeal in May 2026 considered the advance agreement to invoice monthly sufficient for transparency in the circumstances of that case. Its later inadequate performance was a separate matter. These outcomes and the consequences of annulment are discussed in more detail in the analysis of fee clauses.

Other terms remain open to review. In the same case, The Hague Court of Appeal rejected a one-year forfeiture clause falling within Section 6:237(h) DCC. This is a separate issue, discussed in the article on forfeiture clauses in standard terms.

What must the file show?

The provider must substantiate, in sufficient detail, how the contract was concluded and how the applicable information duties were met. Retain the offer, engagement letter, attachments and relevant records of dispatch or receipt. A document giving only an hourly rate does not prove that the other information was supplied. However, general documents describing an ordering process are not automatically excluded: in appropriate circumstances, the court may infer that the particular contract followed that process (Supreme Court 12 November 2021, para. 3.1.17).

Good records can be decisive. An architect who emailed a quotation after office meetings, setting out the work and costs for each phase, recovered the unpaid fees before the Amsterdam Court of Appeal on 18 July 2023. The court could establish that the client had received sufficient information and had been billed in accordance with the quotation (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2023, paras 2.5-2.8).

Frequently asked questions

Do information duties also apply to an oral engagement?

Yes. An oral engagement may also fall within consumer law. The information and form required depend on how the contract is concluded. For an ordinary office engagement, there is no general statutory duty to confirm everything on a durable medium. Written records nevertheless remain important as evidence of what was discussed beforehand.

What is a durable medium?

A means of retaining personally addressed information and consulting it later in an unchanged form. An email or PDF may qualify. An ordinary, changeable webpage or a link to it does not. A protected online account may qualify if the conditions are met, including lasting availability and active notification of new messages.

Does the right of withdrawal also apply to a lawyer?

Generally, yes, for distance and off-premises contracts. The ordinary withdrawal period is fourteen days. Starting work immediately does not automatically remove that right. For paid services, its loss upon full performance requires express prior consent and acknowledgement of that loss. This statutory right of withdrawal does not apply to an ordinary office engagement.

Cited case law

Supreme Court

Opinions of the Advocate General

Courts of appeal

District courts

Disciplinary Appeals Tribunal

Disciplinary Tribunals

See also