Gambling losses and unlicensed online casinos
The Supreme Court decided on 3 July 2026 that the absence of a Dutch licence does not in itself invalidate an online gaming agreement. The prohibition in Section 1 of the Betting and Gaming Act (Wok) is not intended to affect the validity of such agreements (Section 3:40 DCC). Recovery solely on that ground is therefore unavailable. Other grounds, such as misleading conduct or breach of a duty of care, require an assessment of the individual case.
Two players lose well over €100,000 at casinos in Malta
One player lost more than USD 139,000 at Pokerstars between 2006 and 2021; another lost around €135,000 at partycasino.com in 2020-2021. Both casinos (TSG Interactive and Electraworks) are based in Malta and held no licence to offer online games of chance in the Netherlands. Both players sought to recover their losses, arguing that the gaming contract was void.
That question deeply divided the case law. In the case against Trannel (part of Kindred Group, formerly Unibet), the District Court of Overijssel ordered the company to repay €676,224 to a player who, by his own account, stopped 'because the money had run out'. The District Courts of Overijssel and Noord-Nederland held that the agreement was void. Other courts took the opposite line: the District Court of Zeeland-West-Brabant dismissed the claim of a Bwin player (€94,479), and the Amsterdam Court of Appeal had already held, in the Unibet judgment (2016), that a loss of €184,671 was not recoverable.
To end this division, the District Courts of Amsterdam and Noord-Holland referred preliminary questions to the Supreme Court (Section 392 DCCP).
Supreme Court: Section 1 Wok does not affect the validity of the agreement
The Supreme Court holds that agreements with a provider who breaches the prohibition in Section 1 Wok are neither void nor voidable under Section 3:40 DCC. Entering into such an agreement may indeed conflict with a mandatory statutory provision (subsection 2), but subsection 3 does not lead to nullity: from the outset the Wok was never intended to affect the validity of legal acts that conflict with it. The Act provides for administrative and criminal sanctions but is silent on the civil-law consequences.
That interpretation is historically rooted. Under the old Lotteries Act, the Supreme Court still held in 1918 that the purchase of a ticket in a prohibited lottery had an unlawful cause. As early as 1951, the Supreme Court accepted that the purpose of a statutory prohibition on contracting may mean that a breach does not entail nullity. Had the legislature intended nullity when enacting the Wok (1964) or the later Remote Gaming Act, it would have had to say so. It did not. Nor does Section 3:40(1) DCC (conflict with public order or good morals) lead to nullity: applying the standard from the Esmilo/Mediq judgment, the Supreme Court considers that gaming contracts are not in themselves impermissible and that the Wok already provides for sanctions.
Unlike part of the lower-court case law, the Supreme Court therefore does not base this on a 'loss of purpose', the idea that the Wok has lost its original effect through social developments. According to the Supreme Court that purpose simply never existed. It does remain the case that, in certain circumstances, such an agreement may be voidable on account of a defect of consent or may give rise to a claim in tort.
What does this mean for players and providers?
A breach of the licensing requirement alone therefore does not entitle a player to recover their losses. A player seeking repayment or damages must substantiate another ground, such as mistake, an unfair commercial practice or breach of a duty of care. The requirements and rules of evidence differ for each ground.
In the Bwin and Unibet cases discussed, the duty-of-care claims failed in light of the measures taken by the provider and the player’s own responsibility. Those were assessments of the particular gambling behaviour and the standards applicable at the time. They do not establish that the same measures suffice in every period and for every player.
For these consumer claims, the focus therefore shifts to the specific alleged failure and its consequences. How a duty-of-care claim proceeds, what it may yield and whether a judgment can be collected is covered in Can you recover gambling losses from an online casino?
Frequently asked questions
Can I still recover my online gambling losses?
The absence of a Dutch licence is not in itself a ground for repayment. Other grounds, such as misleading conduct or breach of a duty of care, may be relevant. These require concrete facts; the requirements and rules of evidence differ for each ground. The Supreme Court’s ruling does not decide the outcome of every individual damages claim.
What is the difference between nullity and a reliance on mistake or tort?
Nullity concerns the validity of the agreement and may lead to recovery of payments made without a legal basis. Mistake may justify annulment of an agreement. A tort may give a right to damages for a specific breach of a legal duty. A damages claim also requires a causal link between the breach and the loss, and may involve contributory fault.
Does this also apply to a casino with a foreign licence?
Yes. A Maltese or Gibraltarian licence does not replace the required Dutch licence. The provider may therefore be acting in breach of Section 1 Wok. According to the Supreme Court, that breach does not in itself make the agreement void or voidable under Section 3:40 DCC. Other grounds require separate assessment.
Cited case law
Supreme Court
- Supreme Court 3 July 2026, ECLI:NL:HR:2026:1159: Lack of a licence does not invalidate the agreement under Section 3:40 DCC; defects of consent and tort remain possible (paras 3.2.3-3.2.7).
- Supreme Court 1 June 2012, ECLI:NL:HR:2012:BU5609: A prohibited performance does not automatically invalidate an agreement; the court must assess the interests protected and statutory sanctions (para. 4.4).
- Supreme Court 11 May 1951, ECLI:NL:HR:1951:AG1976: Historical judgment: the purpose of a prohibition on contracting may mean that its breach does not entail nullity.
- Supreme Court 15 February 1918, ECLI:NL:HR:1918:112: Under the former law, an unlawful cause prevented recovery of a prize under a prohibited lottery agreement.
Advocate General’s Opinion
- Advocate General Lindenbergh 28 November 2025, ECLI:NL:PHR:2025:1302: Advises against nullity and discusses less far-reaching remedies; this is the opinion preceding the Supreme Court’s decision (point 9.2).
Courts of Appeal
- Amsterdam Court of Appeal 25 October 2016, ECLI:NL:GHAMS:2016:4212: At the time, accepted a loss of statutory purpose and found no duty-of-care breach on the particular facts (paras 3.6-3.13).
District Courts
- Overijssel District Court 19 June 2024, ECLI:NL:RBOVE:2024:3191: Before the Supreme Court’s decision, held the agreement void and awarded €676,224.77 (para. 5.10).
- Zeeland-West-Brabant District Court 29 May 2024, ECLI:NL:RBZWB:2024:3524: Before the Supreme Court’s decision, accepted a loss of statutory purpose; the duty-of-care claim also failed on the particular facts (paras 5.9-5.13 and 5.17-5.21).
- Northern Netherlands District Court 22 May 2024, ECLI:NL:RBNNE:2024:1971: Before the Supreme Court’s decision, held the agreement void and limited repayment to the net loss (paras 4.35-4.39).