Skip to content

Giving a child up for adoption without the father’s knowledge: rights and agencies’ duties

1 November 2026Juriaan de Vries

Fathers’ rights and agency duties in adoption

A child given up without the father’s knowledge may still be adopted later. In 2026, a court allowed adoption, refused contact at that stage and ordered six-monthly updates for a father who had by then become a legal parent. The case shows why the father’s legal position and the agencies’ duties require separate assessment.

The father learnt of the adoption plan afterwards

The child had lived with the prospective adoptive parents for more than three years when the court considered adoption. The mother had given the child up without the father’s knowledge. He wanted to take on a parental role and ultimately bring up the child himself. By then, he had become the legal father and could oppose adoption as a parent. The court heard him in the ongoing proceedings.

The Child Protection Board (Raad voor de Kinderbescherming) advised against adoption and proposed a parental role for the father, with more frequent contact while the child remained with the carers. The court reached a different conclusion. The child’s long-term home was with the prospective adoptive parents, and the court considered the proposed parental role insufficiently workable. It recognised the pain caused by the father’s exclusion but gave priority to the child’s current interests (Oost-Brabant District Court 2026, paras 3.9-3.16).

The Oost-Brabant District Court refused to order contact at that stage. Introducing the child to the father needed to fit with the child’s developing identity and what they were being told about their biological origins. The court considered it inappropriate to start building an attachment to the father immediately. The prospective adoptive parents were, however, required to inform the father once every six months about the child’s development and what the child had been told about their biological origins. The order did not rule out future contact (Oost-Brabant District Court 2026, paras 3.28-3.35).

The adoption decision, the possibilities for contact and the care taken earlier in the process each require a separate assessment. The court did not rule on any agency’s liability in this case.

Adoption requires an assessment of the parent’s future role

Adoption makes the adoptive parents the child’s parents in law. Once an adoption by two new parents becomes final, the legal family ties with the original parents end (Section 1:229 of the Dutch Civil Code (DCC)). An adoption must be manifestly in the child’s interests. It must also be established, and reasonably foreseeable for the future, that the child has nothing further to expect from the original parent or parents in their capacity as parents. That test is set out in Section 1:227(3) DCC.

A further condition for granting adoption is, in principle, that neither legal parent opposes the petition. The court may override such opposition in certain circumstances, including where the parent and child have never, or only rarely, lived together as a family (Section 1:228(2) DCC). That does not, by itself, establish that the child has nothing further to expect from that parent. Each requirement calls for a separate assessment.

In the Oost-Brabant case, the court was entitled to override the father’s objection because he had never lived with the child as a family. It looked further when assessing his future parental role. In its view, his wish to bring up the child himself, the tensions with the carers and the child’s existing attachments made the role proposed by the Board insufficiently realistic. The possibility that contact with the father might become meaningful did not, in those circumstances, preclude adoption (Oost-Brabant District Court 2026, paras 3.11-3.16).

A biological father with protected family life may count as a parent for that test and have standing as an interested party in the adoption proceedings. The statutory right to oppose adoption is reserved to legal parents. Sustained attention, affection and responsibility may form part of a parental role. In a case concerning a known donor who already had contact with his child, the Supreme Court considered the father’s efforts and the scope for involvement allowed by the carers. His limited role up to that point did not, by itself, determine his future significance (Supreme Court, 21 April 2006, paras 3.3-3.4).

Positive involvement helped prevent adoption in another case

In 2016, the Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal considered the case of a father who had learnt of his daughter only about eighteen months after her birth. This was before the district court made the adoption order. On appeal, he was granted permission to acknowledge paternity, became the legal father and began supervised contact. The child continued to live with the foster parents.

The Court of Appeal placed considerable weight on the fact that contact was going well. The father respected the existing care arrangements, wanted to remain involved and could support his daughter. His potential role after she reached adulthood also mattered. The court rejected the adoption petition on appeal: it had not been sufficiently established that the child had nothing further to expect from him as a parent (Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal 2016, paras 2.13-2.15).

The difference lay partly in whether continued involvement alongside the existing care arrangements was workable. Both adoption proceedings were still ongoing. These decisions therefore do not answer whether an adoption order that has already become final can be set aside.

What can a biological father without legal parenthood seek?

A biological father who is not a legal parent and learns of the child only after the child has been given up for adoption does not automatically have a right to contact or information. Biological parentage alone does not establish a close personal relationship, the personal bond referred to in Section 1:377a DCC alongside parenthood. Even without that bond, the protection of his private life may require a substantive assessment. He must substantiate his alleged paternity and the relevant circumstances (Supreme Court, 10 December 2021, paras 3.3-3.5).

The wish to know a biological child may form a significant part of a person’s identity and private life. In Anayo v Germany, the courts had to examine whether contact could serve the children’s interests, despite the rejection of the father’s attempts at contact. In Schneider v Germany, that protection also extended to information while paternity remained disputed. Both cases concerned an existing legally recognised family without adoption. They required an individual balancing of interests without prescribing the outcome (ECtHR, Anayo, §§60-62 and 67-73; Schneider, §§90 and 102-104).

That assessment must consider why no bond was formed and what efforts the father made to become involved. The court must also weigh the significance of contact or information for this child against the risk of disrupting the existing family life (Supreme Court, 10 December 2021, paras 3.5-3.6).

Contact and information each require a separate assessment. An obligation to provide information may be less, but also more burdensome for the parents bringing up the child than contact (opinion preceding the Supreme Court’s decision of 10 December 2021, point 3.36). The six-monthly updates ordered in 2026 therefore set no fixed benchmark. Their content and frequency depend on the child, the father’s position and the effects on the adoptive family.

For contact to take place, the child may also need to know who their biological father is. Providing that explanation forms part of the responsibilities of parents with parental authority and serves the child’s developing identity. Those parents generally decide the appropriate time. The court may, however, determine that the child’s interests require the explanation to be given before contact takes place (Supreme Court, 18 March 2016, paras 5.1.3-5.1.6).

Agencies have different roles in relinquishment for adoption

Several agencies are involved when a child is given up for adoption within the Netherlands. A support organisation assists the mother as she considers giving the child up for adoption. The Child Protection Board examines the legal position and informs the court. A certified child protection agency (GI) may act as guardian and be responsible for the child’s placement and support. Each organisation has its own role. The decision on adoption rests with the court.

The 2023-2025 Protocol on Relinquishment for Adoption set out specific expectations for the organisations involved. The adviser discusses the father’s involvement with the mother and encourages her to inform him. If she refuses, her reasons must be recorded; if he cannot be found, the attempts to trace him must be recorded. As far as possible, the final report should describe his identity and position (Annex 3 and Section C8). Throughout the proceedings, the Board must also consider the potential role of the father and his family in the child’s upbringing. The protocol recommends consulting a legal specialist on this issue (explanatory note B2).

The protocol is a professional guide, allowing departures in clients’ interests and in consultation with clients and the other agencies involved. Each organisation remains subject to its own professional standards. It does not require every father to be contacted directly against the mother’s wishes. A particular case must be assessed under the version and standards applicable at the time. The version discussed here was adopted in October 2023 and states that it is valid until the end of 2025. Section 3.3 of the Dutch Youth Act (Jeugdwet) also requires the Board and the GI to present relevant facts fully and truthfully in reports and petitions.

The State must protect the father’s position in good time

A father excluded from the process may obtain protection under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). That provision protects family life and private life. In Keegan v Ireland, the parents had lived together, were engaged and had decided together to have a child. Yet the child was placed with prospective adoptive parents without the father’s knowledge. The European Court of Human Rights held that this had placed him at a disadvantage that was difficult to reverse. The secret placement violated his existing family life (ECtHR, Keegan, §§44-45 and 50-55).

Keegan concerns the State’s responsibility. It shows why timely involvement matters: attachments formed during a placement may make a later return more difficult. In K.A.B. v Spain and Uzbyakov v Russia, the Court also examined the authorities’ conduct. They could not hold the lack of contact and the passage of time entirely against the father where their own failings had contributed to them. In both cases, a bond with the child already existed.

Further investigation may also be necessary where legal paternity has not been established. In I.V. v Estonia, paternity proceedings were known to be pending. The child was nevertheless adopted without the alleged father’s involvement. The Court found the investigations and balancing of interests inadequate. In those particular circumstances, referring only to the absence of legal paternity was insufficient. At the same time, the Court emphasised that a biological link alone does not automatically create a duty to involve every father in adoption proceedings (ECtHR, I.V., §§95-106).

Confidentiality requires a separate balancing of interests

The father’s rights must be considered alongside the privacy and safety of the mother and child. Violence or threats may provide compelling reasons not to contact the father directly. An adviser must carefully assess and record those interests. The information the Board needs for its statutory role requires a separate assessment.

Section 1:240 DCC permits a person bound by confidentiality to disclose information to the Board without consent where this may be considered necessary for its duties. The provision does not impose a general reporting obligation. Nor does it provide a general power to disclose confidential information directly to the father. An objection from the mother therefore does not remove each agency’s responsibility to make and record its own assessment.

What can follow from excluding the father without due care?

Inadequate investigation or withholding relevant information may amount to a procedural defect. Whether the adoption can then be prevented or challenged is a separate question. The father’s procedural position, the available remedies and the child’s current interests all matter. In 2026, the Amsterdam Court of Appeal found that a GI had taken insufficient initiative to restore contact, but nevertheless upheld the adoption of a fourteen-year-old. The child’s age and own wishes made the situation materially different from a baby being given up without the father’s knowledge (Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2026, paras 5.18-5.24).

A damages claim against the State must take account of the Board’s own role. Its investigation must serve the child’s interests. It considers the parents’ views and interests to the extent that the child’s interests require. The Board has scope for professional judgment: the question is whether the information obtained reasonably allowed it to assess what the child needed. An investigation that lacks due care may make the State liable. The fact that the family court used the report does not automatically exclude that liability (Supreme Court, 19 October 2018, paras 3.4.4-3.4.5 and 3.5.2-3.5.3).

An allegation against a private support organisation must be assessed by reference to its own role and the standard of professional care. The State’s duties under Article 8 ECHR do not automatically make such an organisation liable in damages. A claim under Section 6:162 DCC requires, among other things, unlawful conduct for which the organisation is responsible and loss caused by that conduct. Establishing that causal link may be particularly difficult: what would have been decided differently if the father had been involved in time?

Establishing the legal position therefore requires specific information from the case records: which agency knew of the father and when, what was known about his relationship with the mother, what assessment was made, and what information did the court receive? These facts connect the two aspects of the case: protecting the father during the process and assessing his later requests.

Frequently asked questions about fathers and adoption

Does adoption prevent any subsequent contact arrangement?

No. Where a child already had contact with a parent whose legal family ties end through adoption, the district court may preserve that contact (Section 1:229(5) DCC). The Supreme Court upheld annual contact after adoption by a parent’s partner. Unlike secret relinquishment, that case involved an existing bond with the biological father.

Can a court order DNA testing first?

Yes, following a separate balancing of interests. The court need not first be certain that contact will be granted. Knowledge of biological origins, family stability and the risk that testing may later become impossible all matter. The child’s right to know their biological origins does not give the father an absolute right to DNA testing.

Can the mother decide that the agencies must not inform the father?

A professional must weigh confidentiality, safety and the rights involved in the particular case. A risk of violence may give considerable weight to protecting the mother and child. Disclosure to the Board is also different from contacting the father directly. Each disclosure requires its own legal authority and assessment of necessity.

Relevant case law

The decisions below supplement or qualify the analysis. The Supreme Court entries also include advisory opinions by the Advocate General or Procurator General. The Court’s rulings determine the legal rules. Not every case concerns a child given up without the father’s knowledge.

European Court of Human Rights:

Supreme Court:

Courts of Appeal:

District Courts:

See also