Privilege when the Tax Administration shares documents
A lawyer files documents to defend a client in tax proceedings. Those documents can reach the FIOD through the Tax Administration. May confidential information from that defence then be used in a criminal investigation? On 17 November 2026, the Supreme Court clarified which information remains protected and why attachments do not automatically attract legal professional privilege (verschoningsrecht).
Investigating judge asks Supreme Court about tax attachments
The questions came from the investigating judge (rechter-commissaris) at Oost-Brabant District Court, in criminal proceedings against eight individuals and seven companies. The Supreme Court's decision does not describe the underlying facts. The questions concern documents that the Tax Administration provides to investigating authorities and their attachments.
The investigating judge asked whether attachments to a document filed by a lawyer in a tax dispute are privileged regardless of their content, and whether the same applies to documents from the preliminary and administrative objection stages. The judge also asked whether attaching a document to a confidential communication is itself enough to protect it, what to do if nobody can establish a document's origin, and what happens when the tax dispute and the criminal suspicion concern the same conduct (Supreme Court 17 November 2026, para. 2.1).
According to the Supreme Court, the answers to the first four questions are already implicit in earlier case law. The fifth did not arise in the criminal proceedings, according to the investigating judge. An answer was therefore unnecessary to decide the case, leaving a requirement for a reference for a preliminary ruling unmet (Supreme Court 17 November 2026, paras 2.4.1-2.4.2; Section 553(1) of the Dutch Code of Criminal Procedure (Sv)). The Supreme Court decided immediately, on the advice of the Advocate General, as Section 554(1) Sv permits.
All the questions centred on one sentence in a March 2025 decision. It stated that privilege survives and that this also applies to any attachments. The investigating judge read that as protecting every attachment. Three questions determine what that decision means: does privilege survive filing in tax proceedings, what is the position for attachments, and when is protection nevertheless lost?
Privilege survives tax proceedings
In the March 2025 case, a lawyer had filed a further written submission in a tax dispute before Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal, attaching fourteen witness statements given before a notary. The tax inspector passed the submission to the Dutch financial and tax crime investigation service (FIOD) and the Public Prosecution Service under Section 43c of the AWR Implementing Regulations 1994, made under the General Tax Act (AWR). It became part of the basis for a suspicion that the lawyer's clients had breached the Gambling Act and committed money laundering (Supreme Court 25 March 2025, paras 2.1 and 5.3).
The District Court and investigating judges held that the lawyer had waived privilege: submitting a document to a court put it in the public domain (Supreme Court 25 March 2025, para. 3.4). Advocate General Spronken took a different view. A written submission becomes known only to the court and the opposing party, and remains confidential towards others. In her view, the inspector's knowledge of the document did not make the FIOD a party to that confidence. The need for a statutory basis for passing it on instead underlined that the inspector and FIOD are different bodies (opinion of Advocate General Spronken 3 December 2024, paras 6.19-6.21).
The Supreme Court held the statutory challenge (beklag) inadmissible. In additional observations, it nevertheless reached the same substantive conclusion as the Advocate General. In that situation, filing a document in tax proceedings did not waive privilege for subsequent criminal proceedings. An important limit concerns information the tax court includes in its public judgment: that information is no longer confidential, and the court is free to decide what to include (Supreme Court 25 March 2025, paras 5.4-5.5). This accords with the rule that a lawyer who shows documents to an opposing party retains protection against others (Supreme Court 21 May 2021, para. 5.2.2).
The reason lies in the client's interests. Privilege exists so that everyone can consult a lawyer freely and without fear of disclosure (Supreme Court 22 September 2026, para. 3.4.1). If bringing proceedings cost that protection, a taxpayer would have to choose between challenging an assessment and preserving the confidentiality of information entrusted to a lawyer.
Origin, content and context determine protection of attachments
Privilege covers information entrusted to a lawyer in the ordinary course of legal practice (Supreme Court 9 February 2021, para. 4.2.1). That standard applies to each document. Whether an attachment is protected therefore depends on its contents. The sentence from 2025 means only that privileged information retains that character when included in an attachment to a submission in tax proceedings. The same applies to documents a lawyer provides to the inspector at the preliminary or administrative objection stage (Supreme Court 17 November 2026, para. 2.3).
The document's origin, content and relationship with other documents all matter. The Supreme Court illustrated this two months earlier in a case involving a notary. A document available to anyone from a public register is not, as such, privileged. The position may differ where it forms part of documents that are protected (Supreme Court 22 September 2026, para. 4.2). By contrast, the Advocate General noted that the witness statements in the 2025 case had been prepared with the lawyer's assistance and that the notary had merely recorded what the witnesses said (opinion of Advocate General Spronken 3 December 2024, para. 6.5).
An unknown origin may give rise to disagreement about which information is protected. The starting point is that the lawyer determines what falls within privilege. The inspector and court must respect that position unless there can reasonably be no doubt that it is incorrect (Supreme Court 21 May 2021, para. 5.2.1). In practice, it helps to identify the information considered protected and explain why. The Supreme Court refers to earlier case law for the first four questions, but does not spell out the allocation of responsibilities where the origin is unknown (Supreme Court 17 November 2026, para. 2.4.1).
The same conduct: the question left open
The fifth question concerns an approach developed in Amsterdam. In the Greenhill dividend-stripping investigation, a defendant is being prosecuted for directing the submission of incorrect dividend tax refund claims by two pension funds for 2013 to 2016 (feitelijk leidinggeven). The Tax Administration had corresponded extensively about those claims with the funds' advisers, including a lawyer specialising in tax. On 1 July 2022, it transferred the tax assessment files, including that correspondence, at the FIOD's request (Amsterdam investigating judge 2025).
The investigating judge held that privilege had also been waived for the criminal proceedings. Two circumstances were decisive. The information had been provided to establish the tax liability, while the criminal suspicion concerned precisely that conduct. It had also been provided to the inspector, while Tax Administration officials also investigate tax offences under Section 80(1) AWR. According to the investigating judge, that essential feature was absent from the March 2025 case. The judge followed an earlier Amsterdam decision concerning corporation tax returns (Amsterdam investigating judge 2025; Amsterdam investigating judge 2022).
Advocate General Spronken's reasoning offers another perspective. In her view, the inspector and FIOD are different bodies, although both form part of the Tax Administration, and the inspector's duty of confidentiality is separate from the lawyer's privilege. At the same time, she noted that no tax offence was being prosecuted in her case and expressly distinguished the 2022 Amsterdam decision (opinion of Advocate General Spronken 3 December 2024, paras 6.21-6.23). The Supreme Court also confined its 2025 observations to cases such as the one before it (Supreme Court 25 March 2025, paras 5.1 and 5.3).
There are thus two readings. Under one, the opposing party in the tax dispute also has investigatory powers, and information the lawyer disclosed to it about that conduct is no longer confidential. Under the other, merely moving information from tax assessment to criminal investigation does not remove existing protection. The Oost-Brabant investigating judge referred the question, but it did not arise in that case. In Greenhill, the Public Prosecution Service itself asked, in the alternative, for questions to be referred about correspondence provided under the duty to supply tax information (Amsterdam District Court 2025). The Supreme Court has yet to answer that question.
Investigating judge before disclosure, criminal court afterwards
Protection is arranged before disclosure. If there are reasonable grounds to suspect that the Tax Administration is about to provide privileged information, the public prosecutor must ask the investigating judge to select the material before it is provided. The lawyer is generally heard, or otherwise an authoritative member of the profession, such as the Dean of the local Bar. Protected information is withheld from the FIOD and Public Prosecution Service unless highly exceptional circumstances require the interests of establishing the truth to prevail. There is no statutory procedure specifically designed for this situation. The Supreme Court derives the procedure from the structure of the Dutch Code of Criminal Procedure, although Section 181 Sv was not designed for it (Supreme Court 25 March 2025, para. 5.6).
The options afterwards are limited. Disclosure under Section 43c cannot be challenged through the statutory beklag procedure: there has been neither seizure nor a formal demand for data, and Section 552a Sv provides no application seeking the removal of documents from the case file (Supreme Court 25 March 2025, para. 4.2). Amsterdam District Court also held that the lawyer had no remedy against the investigating judge's decision releasing the documents. It therefore declared the lawyer's challenge in Greenhill inadmissible (Amsterdam District Court 2025).
That case shows how late the problem can emerge. The files went to the FIOD in July 2022 without the lawyer's knowledge. Only when inspecting the data room in May 2025 did he discover that documents he had written were available to the investigation team. If privileged information is used in evidence, the defence can object. The criminal court decides that objection under Section 359a Sv (Amsterdam District Court 2025; Supreme Court 25 March 2025, para. 5.7).
What does this mean for lawyers in tax disputes?
Assess each attachment on its own content before filing it. An extract or annual accounts from a public register do not become privileged merely by being attached to a written submission. Advice, drafts and records of conversations with the lawyer should be kept separate from those documents, in a separate attachment where necessary.
Record which information is confidential and why when filing it. Confidentiality may arise from the nature of the information and the express wishes of the lawyer and client (Supreme Court 25 March 2025, para. 5.2.1). Clear marking makes it easier to take a position on each document later.
Consider what the tax court may include in its judgment. Information it mentions in a public judgment loses its confidential character, and the court decides what to mention. Take particular care before filing documents where the tax dispute may lead to a criminal suspicion concerning the same conduct, while that situation remains unresolved.
If a criminal investigation emerges, identify the privileged information as early as possible. Ask the public prosecutor and investigating judge for the material to be selected before it is examined. The defence can challenge the use of privileged information as evidence before the criminal court.
Frequently asked questions
Does a tax adviser have privilege against the FIOD?
Advice about a client's tax position attracts an informal privilege based on fair play. Tax advisers as such have no privilege in criminal proceedings. Amsterdam permitted witness examinations, with use confined to the relevant criminal cases. For advisers who had since become lawyers, any claim to privilege had to be assessed for each question (Amsterdam investigating judge 2024).
What allows the Tax Administration to give information to the FIOD?
Section 67 AWR allows ministerial exceptions to tax confidentiality where disclosure is needed for an authority's public duties. Section 43c of the AWR Implementing Regulations 1994 names the FIOD director for criminal law enforcement. Information may also be provided on request, without a formal demand under criminal procedure (Supreme Court 25 March 2025, paras 4.2 and 5.6).
Can an investigating judge refer questions to the Supreme Court?
Yes. Since 1 October 2022, criminal judges, including investigating judges, may ask the Supreme Court a legal question necessary for their decision and of wider significance. Prosecution and defence may request a reference and are heard beforehand on the proposal and wording (Section 553 Sv; Supreme Court 13 June 2023, paras 3.1-3.3.1).
Cited case law
Supreme Court
- Supreme Court 17 November 2026, ECLI:NL:HR:2026:1940: declined to answer questions referred for a preliminary ruling; attachments are assessed by origin, content and context, paras 2.1-2.4.2.
- Supreme Court 22 September 2026, ECLI:NL:HR:2026:1527: basis of privilege; public-register documents are not privileged as such, paras 3.4.1 and 4.2.
- Supreme Court 25 March 2025, ECLI:NL:HR:2025:456: filing in tax proceedings does not waive privilege; selection by the investigating judge before disclosure under Section 43c, paras 4.2 and 5.1-5.7.
- Supreme Court 13 June 2023, ECLI:NL:HR:2023:913: requirements for references for a preliminary ruling in criminal proceedings, para. 3.3.1.
- Supreme Court 21 May 2021, ECLI:NL:HR:2021:751: the lawyer generally determines what is privileged; sharing with an opposing party leaves protection against others intact, paras 5.2.1-5.2.2.
- Supreme Court 9 February 2021, ECLI:NL:HR:2021:193: privilege covers information entrusted in the ordinary course of professional practice, para. 4.2.1.
Opinions
- Opinion of Advocate General Spronken 3 December 2024, ECLI:NL:PHR:2024:1301: a written submission becomes known only to the court and opposing party; the inspector and FIOD are different bodies, paras 6.5 and 6.19-6.23.
District Courts
- Amsterdam District Court 2 December 2025, ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2025:9497: no statutory challenge against the investigating judge's decision; privilege can be raised in an objection to the use of evidence.
- Amsterdam investigating judge 19 August 2025, ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2025:7308: privilege over correspondence with the Tax Administration about the same conduct was also waived for the criminal proceedings.
- Amsterdam investigating judge 1 March 2024, ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2024:1425: tax advisers may be examined as witnesses; statements usable only in the criminal cases.
- Amsterdam investigating judge 4 October 2022, ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2022:6249: privilege over information provided to the inspector about the same conduct was also waived for subsequent criminal proceedings.