Skip to content

Compound interest on a loan: without an express stipulation, simple interest applies

2 June 2026Juriaan de Vries

Compound interest on a loan

A lender wishing to charge interest on interest that has already fallen due needs a legal basis. For contractual interest, the starting point is simple interest unless compounding has been agreed. Statutory interest and claims covered by the statutory commercial interest regime follow different rules. The distinction determines how much the debtor ultimately owes.

The creditor must prove the interest terms

On 27 January 2010 the Rotterdam District Court held that compounding contractual interest requires an agreement. Hofman & Hofman B.V. claimed to have made a long-term loan and calculated interest on both the principal and overdue interest. The other party disputed the loan and the interest terms. The court allowed Hofman to prove those terms, including an agreement to compound. The interest dispute had therefore not yet been finally decided (Rotterdam District Court 2010, paras 4.11-4.15).

The creditor had argued that the method of Section 6:119 of the Dutch Civil Code, which lets statutory interest compound automatically, may be applied by analogy to contractual interest. The District Court rejected that route. For contractual interest there is no comparable statutory provision, and the court saw insufficient ground for an analogy.

Statutory and contractual interest follow different rules

The distinction lies in the structure of Section 6:119 DCC. Subsection 2 provides that the amount on which statutory interest is calculated is increased, at the end of each year, by the interest due for that year. On its wording that compounding rule covers statutory interest alone. Contractual interest is dealt with in subsection 3. That subsection does no more than provide that an agreed rate higher than the statutory rate keeps running once the debtor is in default. On the method of calculation it is silent.

Advocate General Timmerman inferred from the legislative history that agreed interest is in principle calculated on a simple basis. When comparing it with statutory interest, the annual compounding of statutory interest must also be taken into account. A higher contractual percentage therefore does not settle the comparison by itself. The Advocate General found support for this reading in the legal literature (Advocate General Timmerman 10 July 2009, para. 3.4).

The argument in cassation was that delay exceeding a year is fully compensated only through compounding. The Advocate General considered this insufficient to extend Section 6:119(2) DCC to contractual interest by analogy. The statutory structure and the parties’ agreement remained decisive (Advocate General Timmerman 10 July 2009, paras 3.3-3.6).

What the 2009 judgment does and does not settle

Supreme Court 9 October 2009 is often cited on this point, and caution is called for. That case was a dispute over deliveries of plant material, with an agreed rate of 2 per cent a month. The Court of Appeal in Amsterdam had held that compound interest was not payable absent a stipulation. The Supreme Court dismissed the complaints against it under Section 81 of the Judiciary (Organisation) Act. It therefore gave no substantive reasons (Supreme Court 9 October 2009). What the judgment yields is that the Court of Appeal's holding survived review in cassation, rather than a rule formulated by the Supreme Court itself.

There is a further reason to cite the judgment with care. In the cross-appeal the Supreme Court set aside that same Amsterdam judgment of 12 April 2007 and referred the case to the Court of Appeal in The Hague. That setting aside rested on a different element, the fee under the Seeds and Planting Materials Act, but the operative part does not confine it to that element.

The older case also involved transitional law. The statutory commercial interest regime did not apply to the agreement made before its introduction, a point the Advocate General addressed separately. In 2020 the Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal accordingly warned against reading the judgment as establishing simple interest for every claim covered by that regime (Advocate General Timmerman 10 July 2009, para. 3.5; Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal 2020, paras 6.3-6.6 and 6.14).

The exception for statutory commercial interest

The position differs where Section 6:119a DCC applies to the claim. Subsection 9 equates another agreed rate with statutory interest for the purposes of that section. Subsection 3 provides for annual compounding. The Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal applied the combination to the business element of an accountant’s invoices (Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal 2020, paras 6.3-6.5).

The court distinguished work winding up businesses from work on a private matrimonial property division. Contractual interest compounded on the first element and remained simple on the second. The client’s intention to use the proceeds of the property division in his business did not turn private services into a commercial transaction. The nature of the services was decisive (Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal 2020, paras 6.9-6.13). This case concerned services, not repayment of a loan. The parties’ business status alone therefore does not establish that the exception applies to every loan.

What does this mean in a dispute about interest?

Start with the complete interest terms. Do they govern only the rate, or also the capitalisation of overdue interest? Do they specify when interest is added and the amount on which interest then accrues? A monthly percentage does not by itself prove an agreement to compound. In the Rotterdam case the creditor first had to prove the alleged agreement.

Next identify the applicable statutory interest regime. For a loan between family members or friends acting entirely privately, the commercial interest regime provides no basis for compounding. In a business relationship, the application of Section 6:119a DCC must be established separately. Keep the starting date, payments and any limitation of interest claims distinct.

The sources discussed therefore distinguish contractual interest, ordinary statutory interest and commercial interest. The 2009 judgment gives no substantive reasons of its own on compounding. The Advocate General’s opinion and the 2020 appeal judgment do provide that analysis. Their different authority should remain clear when supporting an interest calculation.

Frequently asked questions

Does the simple default also apply where statutory interest is claimed?

No. Section 6:119(2) DCC provides for annual compounding of statutory interest. Contractual terms require interpretation: linking the rate to statutory interest plus a margin does not itself prove an agreement to capitalise interest. Where the commercial interest regime applies, Section 6:119a DCC provides separate rules.

When is a stipulation for interest on interest sufficiently clear?

State expressly that overdue interest is capitalised, how often, and the amount on which interest subsequently accrues. Whether an existing clause permits compounding requires interpretation of the complete agreement. Naming a monthly rate alone does not provide sufficient clarity.

Can a creditor base compounding on full compensation of its loss?

That argument did not succeed in the 2009 proceedings discussed here. The Advocate General considered full compensation insufficient to apply Section 6:119(2) DCC by analogy. The Supreme Court dismissed the interest complaints without substantive reasons. The agreement and the applicable statutory regime therefore remain the starting point.

Cited case law

Supreme Court

Advocate General’s opinion

Courts of Appeal

District Courts

See also